In-Context Explainers: Harnessing LLMs for Explaining Black Box Models
0
🌐
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional capabilities in complex tasks like machine translation, commonsense reasoning, and language understanding.
- The adaptability of LLMs in such diverse tasks is largely due to their in-context learning (ICL) capability, which allows them to perform well on new tasks by using a few task samples in the prompt.
- While ICL has been effective in enhancing the performance of LLMs on various language and tabular tasks, its potential to generate post hoc explanations has not been thoroughly explored.
- This paper presents a novel framework, "In-Context Explainers," which exploits the ICL capabilities of LLMs to explain the predictions made by other predictive models.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are powerful AI systems that can perform a wide range of complex tasks, such as translating between languages, understanding common sense, and comprehending language. One of the key reasons these models are so adaptable is their in-context learning (ICL) capability, which allows them to learn and perform new tasks using just a few examples provided in the input prompt.
While ICL has been shown to be effective in boosting the performance of LLMs on various tasks, the researchers in this study wanted to explore whether these models could also be used to explain the predictions made by other complex AI models. To do this, they developed a new framework called "In-Context Explainers," which uses the ICL capabilities of LLMs to generate explanations for the outputs of other predictive models.
The researchers tested their framework on real-world datasets, both text-based and tabular, and found that LLMs were able to provide explanations for the predictions of other models that were similar in quality to state-of-the-art post hoc explainers. This suggests that LLMs could be a promising avenue for future research into generating easy-to-understand explanations for complex AI systems.
Technical Explanation
The researchers propose a novel framework called "In-Context Explainers" that leverages the in-context learning (ICL) capabilities of LLMs to explain the predictions made by other complex predictive models. The framework comprises three approaches:
- Prompt-based Explainer: This approach generates explanations by appending a prompt to the input data that asks the LLM to explain the prediction.
- Template-based Explainer: This approach uses a predefined natural language template that the LLM fills in with relevant information to explain the prediction.
- Iterative Explainer: This approach iteratively refines the explanation by prompting the LLM to elaborate on or clarify parts of the initial explanation.
The researchers evaluated these approaches on both text-based and tabular datasets, comparing the explanations generated by the LLM-based explainers to those produced by state-of-the-art post hoc explainers. They found that the LLM-based explainers were able to generate explanations that were comparable in quality to the post hoc methods, demonstrating the potential of using language models to provide natural language explanations for complex predictive models.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge several limitations and areas for future research in their work. For example, they note that the effectiveness of the In-Context Explainers may be sensitive to the specific prompts or templates used, and further investigation is needed to understand how to design effective prompts. Additionally, the researchers suggest that the quality of the explanations generated by the LLMs could be improved by fine-tuning the models on larger datasets of explanation examples.
One potential concern that is not addressed in the paper is the issue of model robustness and reliability when using LLMs to generate explanations. LLMs can sometimes produce plausible-sounding but factually incorrect outputs, and it's important to ensure that the explanations they generate are trustworthy and accurately reflect the reasoning of the underlying predictive model.
Overall, this research represents an interesting and promising step towards using the powerful capabilities of large language models to provide natural language explanations for complex AI systems. However, further work is needed to fully understand the strengths, limitations, and potential pitfalls of this approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel framework called "In-Context Explainers" that leverages the in-context learning capabilities of large language models to explain the predictions made by other complex predictive models. Through extensive testing on real-world datasets, the researchers demonstrated that LLMs are capable of generating explanations that are comparable in quality to state-of-the-art post hoc explainers.
This work opens up exciting avenues for future research into using language models to provide natural language explanations for AI systems, which could have important implications for improving the transparency and trustworthiness of complex predictive models. However, further investigation is needed to address potential limitations, such as the sensitivity of the approach to prompting and the issue of model robustness and reliability.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🌐
0
In-Context Explainers: Harnessing LLMs for Explaining Black Box Models
Nicholas Kroeger, Dan Ley, Satyapriya Krishna, Chirag Agarwal, Himabindu Lakkaraju
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional capabilities in complex tasks like machine translation, commonsense reasoning, and language understanding. One of the primary reasons for the adaptability of LLMs in such diverse tasks is their in-context learning (ICL) capability, which allows them to perform well on new tasks by simply using a few task samples in the prompt. Despite their effectiveness in enhancing the performance of LLMs on diverse language and tabular tasks, these methods have not been thoroughly explored for their potential to generate post hoc explanations. In this work, we carry out one of the first explorations to analyze the effectiveness of LLMs in explaining other complex predictive models using ICL. To this end, we propose a novel framework, In-Context Explainers, comprising of three novel approaches that exploit the ICL capabilities of LLMs to explain the predictions made by other predictive models. We conduct extensive analysis with these approaches on real-world tabular and text datasets and demonstrate that LLMs are capable of explaining other predictive models similar to state-of-the-art post hoc explainers, opening up promising avenues for future research into LLM-based post hoc explanations of complex predictive models.
Read more7/12/2024
0
Large Language Models Know What Makes Exemplary Contexts
Quanyu Long, Jianda Chen, Wenya Wang, Sinno Jialin Pan
In-context learning (ICL) has proven to be a significant capability with the advancement of Large Language models (LLMs). By instructing LLMs using few-shot demonstrative examples, ICL enables them to perform a wide range of tasks without needing to update millions of parameters. This paper presents a unified framework for LLMs that allows them to self-select influential in-context examples to compose their contexts; self-rank candidates with different demonstration compositions; self-optimize the demonstration selection and ordering through reinforcement learning. Specifically, our method designs a parameter-efficient retrieval head that generates the optimized demonstration after training with rewards from LLM's own preference. Experimental results validate the proposed method's effectiveness in enhancing ICL performance. Additionally, our approach effectively identifies and selects the most representative examples for the current task, and includes more diversity in retrieval.
Read more8/21/2024
💬
0
Large Language Models are In-context Teachers for Knowledge Reasoning
Jiachen Zhao, Zonghai Yao, Zhichao Yang, Hong Yu
Chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting teaches large language models (LLMs) in context to reason over queries that require more than mere information retrieval. However, human experts are usually required to craft demonstrations for in-context learning (ICL), which is expensive and has high variance. More importantly, how to craft helpful reasoning exemplars for ICL remains unclear. In this work, we investigate whether LLMs can be better in-context teachers for knowledge reasoning. We follow the ``encoding specificity'' hypothesis in human's memory retrieval to assume in-context exemplars at inference should match the encoding context in training data. We are thus motivated to propose Self-Explain to use one LLM's self-elicited explanations as in-context demonstrations for prompting it as they are generalized from the model's training examples. Self-Explain is shown to significantly outperform using human-crafted exemplars and other baselines. We further reveal that for in-context teaching, rationales by distinct teacher LLMs or human experts that more resemble the student LLM's self-explanations are better demonstrations, which supports our encoding specificity hypothesis. We then propose Teach-Back that aligns the teacher LLM with the student to enhance the in-context teaching performance. For example, Teach-Back enables a 7B model to teach the much larger GPT-3.5 in context, surpassing human teachers by around 5% in test accuracy on medical question answering.
Read more6/18/2024
0
Language Models can Exploit Cross-Task In-context Learning for Data-Scarce Novel Tasks
Anwoy Chatterjee, Eshaan Tanwar, Subhabrata Dutta, Tanmoy Chakraborty
Large Language Models (LLMs) have transformed NLP with their remarkable In-context Learning (ICL) capabilities. Automated assistants based on LLMs are gaining popularity; however, adapting them to novel tasks is still challenging. While colossal models excel in zero-shot performance, their computational demands limit widespread use, and smaller language models struggle without context. This paper investigates whether LLMs can generalize from labeled examples of predefined tasks to novel tasks. Drawing inspiration from biological neurons and the mechanistic interpretation of the Transformer architecture, we explore the potential for information sharing across tasks. We design a cross-task prompting setup with three LLMs and show that LLMs achieve significant performance improvements despite no examples from the target task in the context. Cross-task prompting leads to a remarkable performance boost of 107% for LLaMA-2 7B, 18.6% for LLaMA-2 13B, and 3.2% for GPT 3.5 on average over zero-shot prompting, and performs comparable to standard in-context learning. The effectiveness of generating pseudo-labels for in-task examples is demonstrated, and our analyses reveal a strong correlation between the effect of cross-task examples and model activation similarities in source and target input tokens. This paper offers a first-of-its-kind exploration of LLMs' ability to solve novel tasks based on contextual signals from different task examples.
Read more6/13/2024