On Discovery of Local Independence over Continuous Variables via Neural Contextual Decomposition
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a method called Neural Contextual Decomposition (NCD) for discovering local independence over continuous variables.
- Local independence refers to situations where a variable is independent of another variable, but only in certain contexts or conditions.
- The authors demonstrate how NCD can be used to uncover these local independence relationships, which are important for understanding complex systems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores a new way to find hidden connections between different variables in a dataset. Often, the relationship between two variables depends on the values of other variables in the system. For example, a person's income might be independent of their education level, but only when considering people who live in a certain region.
The authors' method, called Neural Contextual Decomposition (NCD), allows them to identify these types of "local independence" relationships. NCD looks at how the influence of one variable on another changes depending on the values of other variables in the dataset.
By uncovering these local independence patterns, researchers can better understand the underlying structure and dynamics of complex systems. This could lead to improved predictive models, more targeted interventions, and a deeper scientific understanding of the relationships between different factors.
The key advantage of NCD is that it can uncover these nuanced, context-dependent relationships, going beyond simple correlations between variables. This allows for a more accurate and detailed representation of how different components of a system interact.
Technical Explanation
The core innovation of this paper is the Neural Contextual Decomposition (NCD) method, which builds on prior work on causal discovery via conditional independence testing and invariant subspace decomposition.
NCD aims to discover local independence relationships, where a variable X is independent of another variable Y, but only in certain contexts defined by the values of other variables Z. This is an important but challenging problem, as these context-dependent independence relationships are common in complex systems but difficult to detect.
The key steps of the NCD method are:
- Train a neural network model to predict the target variable Y from the input variables X and Z.
- Use the trained model to compute a "contextual decomposition" that separates the influence of X and Z on Y.
- Analyze the contextual decomposition to identify variables X that are locally independent of Y, conditioned on the values of Z.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of NCD on both synthetic and real-world datasets, showing how it can uncover meaningful local independence relationships that would be missed by standard independence testing approaches.
Critical Analysis
The authors provide a thorough evaluation of NCD, including comparisons to alternative methods like enforcing conditional independence for fair representation learning and conditional independence testing in the presence of discretization. The results indicate that NCD is able to reliably detect local independence relationships that other methods miss.
One potential limitation is that NCD, like many machine learning methods, relies on the quality and representativeness of the training data. If the dataset does not capture the full range of relevant contexts, the local independence discoveries may be incomplete or biased.
Additionally, the authors note that NCD can be computationally intensive, as it requires training a neural network model and performing the contextual decomposition analysis. This could limit its scalability to very large datasets or real-time applications.
Overall, the NCD method represents an important advance in the field of conditional independence as a binary relation, providing a powerful tool for uncovering nuanced, context-dependent relationships in complex systems. The research raises interesting questions for future work, such as exploring more efficient implementations or extending the method to handle non-continuous variables.
Conclusion
This paper introduces a novel approach called Neural Contextual Decomposition (NCD) that can uncover local independence relationships over continuous variables. By identifying situations where a variable is independent of another, but only under certain conditions, NCD provides a more detailed and accurate representation of the underlying structure of complex systems.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of NCD through experiments on both synthetic and real-world data, showing how it can discover meaningful patterns that would be missed by standard independence testing methods. While NCD has some computational limitations, it represents an important step forward in understanding the intricate relationships between variables in complex domains.
The insights from this research could have far-reaching implications, from improving predictive models to informing more targeted interventions in fields like healthcare, finance, and social policy. As our world becomes increasingly complex, tools like NCD will be crucial for extracting meaningful insights and advancing our scientific understanding of the world around us.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
On Discovery of Local Independence over Continuous Variables via Neural Contextual Decomposition
Inwoo Hwang, Yunhyeok Kwak, Yeon-Ji Song, Byoung-Tak Zhang, Sanghack Lee
Conditional independence provides a way to understand causal relationships among the variables of interest. An underlying system may exhibit more fine-grained causal relationships especially between a variable and its parents, which will be called the local independence relationships. One of the most widely studied local relationships is Context-Specific Independence (CSI), which holds in a specific assignment of conditioned variables. However, its applicability is often limited since it does not allow continuous variables: data conditioned to the specific value of a continuous variable contains few instances, if not none, making it infeasible to test independence. In this work, we define and characterize the local independence relationship that holds in a specific set of joint assignments of parental variables, which we call context-set specific independence (CSSI). We then provide a canonical representation of CSSI and prove its fundamental properties. Based on our theoretical findings, we cast the problem of discovering multiple CSSI relationships in a system as finding a partition of the joint outcome space. Finally, we propose a novel method, coined neural contextual decomposition (NCD), which learns such partition by imposing each set to induce CSSI via modeling a conditional distribution. We empirically demonstrate that the proposed method successfully discovers the ground truth local independence relationships in both synthetic dataset and complex system reflecting the real-world physical dynamics.
Read more5/14/2024
0
Causal Discovery with Fewer Conditional Independence Tests
Kirankumar Shiragur, Jiaqi Zhang, Caroline Uhler
Many questions in science center around the fundamental problem of understanding causal relationships. However, most constraint-based causal discovery algorithms, including the well-celebrated PC algorithm, often incur an exponential number of conditional independence (CI) tests, posing limitations in various applications. Addressing this, our work focuses on characterizing what can be learned about the underlying causal graph with a reduced number of CI tests. We show that it is possible to a learn a coarser representation of the hidden causal graph with a polynomial number of tests. This coarser representation, named Causal Consistent Partition Graph (CCPG), comprises of a partition of the vertices and a directed graph defined over its components. CCPG satisfies consistency of orientations and additional constraints which favor finer partitions. Furthermore, it reduces to the underlying causal graph when the causal graph is identifiable. As a consequence, our results offer the first efficient algorithm for recovering the true causal graph with a polynomial number of tests, in special cases where the causal graph is fully identifiable through observational data and potentially additional interventions.
Read more6/5/2024
๐งช
0
Causal Discovery via Conditional Independence Testing with Proxy Variables
Mingzhou Liu, Xinwei Sun, Yu Qiao, Yizhou Wang
Distinguishing causal connections from correlations is important in many scenarios. However, the presence of unobserved variables, such as the latent confounder, can introduce bias in conditional independence testing commonly employed in constraint-based causal discovery for identifying causal relations. To address this issue, existing methods introduced proxy variables to adjust for the bias caused by unobserveness. However, these methods were either limited to categorical variables or relied on strong parametric assumptions for identification. In this paper, we propose a novel hypothesis-testing procedure that can effectively examine the existence of the causal relationship over continuous variables, without any parametric constraint. Our procedure is based on discretization, which under completeness conditions, is able to asymptotically establish a linear equation whose coefficient vector is identifiable under the causal null hypothesis. Based on this, we introduce our test statistic and demonstrate its asymptotic level and power. We validate the effectiveness of our procedure using both synthetic and real-world data.
Read more5/3/2024
0
Invariant Subspace Decomposition
Margherita Lazzaretto, Jonas Peters, Niklas Pfister
We consider the task of predicting a response Y from a set of covariates X in settings where the conditional distribution of Y given X changes over time. For this to be feasible, assumptions on how the conditional distribution changes over time are required. Existing approaches assume, for example, that changes occur smoothly over time so that short-term prediction using only the recent past becomes feasible. In this work, we propose a novel invariance-based framework for linear conditionals, called Invariant Subspace Decomposition (ISD), that splits the conditional distribution into a time-invariant and a residual time-dependent component. As we show, this decomposition can be utilized both for zero-shot and time-adaptation prediction tasks, that is, settings where either no or a small amount of training data is available at the time points we want to predict Y at, respectively. We propose a practical estimation procedure, which automatically infers the decomposition using tools from approximate joint matrix diagonalization. Furthermore, we provide finite sample guarantees for the proposed estimator and demonstrate empirically that it indeed improves on approaches that do not use the additional invariant structure.
Read more4/16/2024