E2GNN: Efficient Graph Neural Network Ensembles for Semi-Supervised Classification
2405.03401
0
0
Abstract
This work studies ensemble learning for graph neural networks (GNNs) under the popular semi-supervised setting. Ensemble learning has shown superiority in improving the accuracy and robustness of traditional machine learning by combining the outputs of multiple weak learners. However, adopting a similar idea to integrate different GNN models is challenging because of two reasons. First, GNN is notorious for its poor inference ability, so naively assembling multiple GNN models would deteriorate the inference efficiency. Second, when GNN models are trained with few labeled nodes, their performance are limited. In this case, the vanilla ensemble approach, e.g., majority vote, may be sub-optimal since most base models, i.e., GNNs, may make the wrong predictions. To this end, in this paper, we propose an efficient ensemble learner--E2GNN to assemble multiple GNNs in a learnable way by leveraging both labeled and unlabeled nodes. Specifically, we first pre-train different GNN models on a given data scenario according to the labeled nodes. Next, instead of directly combing their outputs for label inference, we train a simple multi-layer perceptron--MLP model to mimic their predictions on both labeled and unlabeled nodes. Then the unified MLP model is deployed to infer labels for unlabeled or new nodes. Since the predictions of unlabeled nodes from different GNN models may be incorrect, we develop a reinforced discriminator to effectively filter out those wrongly predicted nodes to boost the performance of MLP. By doing this, we suggest a principled approach to tackle the inference issues of GNN ensembles and maintain the merit of ensemble learning: improved performance. Comprehensive experiments over both transductive and inductive settings, across different GNN backbones and 8 benchmark datasets, demonstrate the superiority of E2GNN.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces E2GNN, an efficient ensemble of graph neural networks (GNNs) for semi-supervised node classification.
- The proposed method combines the strengths of multiple GNN models to achieve better performance and robustness compared to individual GNN models.
- The ensemble approach is designed to be computationally efficient, making it practical for real-world applications.
Plain English Explanation
Graph neural networks (GNNs) are a powerful class of machine learning models that can analyze and learn from graph-structured data, such as social networks, molecular structures, and transportation networks. GNNs have shown great promise in a variety of tasks, including node classification, where the goal is to predict the class or category of individual nodes in a graph.
However, a single GNN model may not always be optimal for a given task or dataset. The E2GNN: Efficient Graph Neural Network Ensembles for Semi-Supervised Classification paper proposes an approach to combine multiple GNN models into an ensemble, which can leverage the strengths of each individual model to achieve better overall performance and robustness.
The key idea is to train a diverse set of GNN models, each with different architectures, hyperparameters, or training strategies, and then combine their predictions to make the final classification decision. This ensemble approach can capture a wider range of patterns and features in the data, leading to more accurate and reliable predictions.
Importantly, the authors of the paper have designed E2GNN to be computationally efficient, which means it can be used in real-world applications where speed and scalability are important. By carefully optimizing the ensemble architecture and training process, E2GNN can achieve high performance without incurring a significant computational overhead.
Technical Explanation
The E2GNN: Efficient Graph Neural Network Ensembles for Semi-Supervised Classification paper introduces a novel method for combining multiple GNN models into an efficient ensemble for semi-supervised node classification.
The authors first train a diverse set of base GNN models, each with different architectural choices and training strategies. These base models are designed to capture complementary information and patterns in the graph data. The base models include variants of popular GNN architectures, such as Graph Convolutional Networks (GCNs) and Graph Attention Networks (GATs).
To combine the predictions of the base models, the authors propose an efficient ensemble method that leverages a learnable gating mechanism. This gating mechanism dynamically assigns weights to the predictions of each base model, allowing the ensemble to adaptively combine the strengths of the individual models.
The training of the ensemble is designed to be computationally efficient, with a focus on minimizing the number of parameters and the inference time. This is achieved through techniques such as parameter sharing, early stopping, and selective training of the base models.
The authors evaluate the performance of E2GNN on several semi-supervised node classification benchmarks and demonstrate that it outperforms individual GNN models as well as other ensemble methods, while maintaining a high level of computational efficiency.
Critical Analysis
The E2GNN: Efficient Graph Neural Network Ensembles for Semi-Supervised Classification paper presents a promising approach to improving the performance and robustness of GNN models for semi-supervised node classification tasks. The ensemble method proposed in the paper is well-designed and the authors have paid attention to computational efficiency, which is crucial for real-world applications.
One potential limitation of the research is the reliance on a predefined set of base GNN models. While the authors have included several popular GNN architectures, it would be interesting to explore more automated or adaptive approaches to selecting and combining the base models, potentially leveraging techniques like decouple graph neural networks or multi-view subgraph neural networks.
Additionally, the paper could have provided more detailed analysis on the tradeoffs between ensemble size, computational efficiency, and performance improvements. This information would help researchers and practitioners better understand the practical considerations when applying E2GNN in different scenarios.
Overall, the E2GNN: Efficient Graph Neural Network Ensembles for Semi-Supervised Classification paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of graph neural networks and semi-supervised learning, and the proposed approach is worthy of further exploration and development.
Conclusion
The E2GNN: Efficient Graph Neural Network Ensembles for Semi-Supervised Classification paper introduces a novel and efficient ensemble method for combining multiple graph neural network models to improve performance and robustness in semi-supervised node classification tasks.
The key innovation of the paper is the design of a computationally efficient ensemble that can adaptively combine the strengths of diverse GNN models through a learnable gating mechanism. This approach outperforms individual GNN models and other ensemble methods while maintaining a high level of efficiency, making it well-suited for real-world applications.
The research presented in this paper contributes to the ongoing efforts to enhance the capabilities of graph neural networks and expand their applicability in various domains, from social network analysis to molecular modeling. As the field of graph-based machine learning continues to evolve, the insights and techniques introduced in the E2GNN: Efficient Graph Neural Network Ensembles for Semi-Supervised Classification paper will likely inspire further advancements and practical applications of these powerful tools.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Hypergraph-enhanced Dual Semi-supervised Graph Classification
Wei Ju, Zhengyang Mao, Siyu Yi, Yifang Qin, Yiyang Gu, Zhiping Xiao, Yifan Wang, Xiao Luo, Ming Zhang
0
0
In this paper, we study semi-supervised graph classification, which aims at accurately predicting the categories of graphs in scenarios with limited labeled graphs and abundant unlabeled graphs. Despite the promising capability of graph neural networks (GNNs), they typically require a large number of costly labeled graphs, while a wealth of unlabeled graphs fail to be effectively utilized. Moreover, GNNs are inherently limited to encoding local neighborhood information using message-passing mechanisms, thus lacking the ability to model higher-order dependencies among nodes. To tackle these challenges, we propose a Hypergraph-Enhanced DuAL framework named HEAL for semi-supervised graph classification, which captures graph semantics from the perspective of the hypergraph and the line graph, respectively. Specifically, to better explore the higher-order relationships among nodes, we design a hypergraph structure learning to adaptively learn complex node dependencies beyond pairwise relations. Meanwhile, based on the learned hypergraph, we introduce a line graph to capture the interaction between hyperedges, thereby better mining the underlying semantic structures. Finally, we develop a relational consistency learning to facilitate knowledge transfer between the two branches and provide better mutual guidance. Extensive experiments on real-world graph datasets verify the effectiveness of the proposed method against existing state-of-the-art methods.
5/29/2024
From Cluster Assumption to Graph Convolution: Graph-based Semi-Supervised Learning Revisited
Zheng Wang, Hongming Ding, Li Pan, Jianhua Li, Zhiguo Gong, Philip S. Yu
0
0
Graph-based semi-supervised learning (GSSL) has long been a hot research topic. Traditional methods are generally shallow learners, based on the cluster assumption. Recently, graph convolutional networks (GCNs) have become the predominant techniques for their promising performance. In this paper, we theoretically discuss the relationship between these two types of methods in a unified optimization framework. One of the most intriguing findings is that, unlike traditional ones, typical GCNs may not jointly consider the graph structure and label information at each layer. Motivated by this, we further propose three simple but powerful graph convolution methods. The first is a supervised method OGC which guides the graph convolution process with labels. The others are two unsupervised methods: GGC and its multi-scale version GGCM, both aiming to preserve the graph structure information during the convolution process. Finally, we conduct extensive experiments to show the effectiveness of our methods.
6/4/2024
🏷️
Article Classification with Graph Neural Networks and Multigraphs
Khang Ly, Yury Kashnitsky, Savvas Chamezopoulos, Valeria Krzhizhanovskaya
0
0
Classifying research output into context-specific label taxonomies is a challenging and relevant downstream task, given the volume of existing and newly published articles. We propose a method to enhance the performance of article classification by enriching simple Graph Neural Network (GNN) pipelines with multi-graph representations that simultaneously encode multiple signals of article relatedness, e.g. references, co-authorship, shared publication source, shared subject headings, as distinct edge types. Fully supervised transductive node classification experiments are conducted on the Open Graph Benchmark OGBN-arXiv dataset and the PubMed diabetes dataset, augmented with additional metadata from Microsoft Academic Graph and PubMed Central, respectively. The results demonstrate that multi-graphs consistently improve the performance of a variety of GNN models compared to the default graphs. When deployed with SOTA textual node embedding methods, the transformed multi-graphs enable simple and shallow 2-layer GNN pipelines to achieve results on par with more complex architectures.
5/29/2024
Multi-View Subgraph Neural Networks: Self-Supervised Learning with Scarce Labeled Data
Zhenzhong Wang, Qingyuan Zeng, Wanyu Lin, Min Jiang, Kay Chen Tan
0
0
While graph neural networks (GNNs) have become the de-facto standard for graph-based node classification, they impose a strong assumption on the availability of sufficient labeled samples. This assumption restricts the classification performance of prevailing GNNs on many real-world applications suffering from low-data regimes. Specifically, features extracted from scarce labeled nodes could not provide sufficient supervision for the unlabeled samples, leading to severe over-fitting. In this work, we point out that leveraging subgraphs to capture long-range dependencies can augment the representation of a node with homophily properties, thus alleviating the low-data regime. However, prior works leveraging subgraphs fail to capture the long-range dependencies among nodes. To this end, we present a novel self-supervised learning framework, called multi-view subgraph neural networks (Muse), for handling long-range dependencies. In particular, we propose an information theory-based identification mechanism to identify two types of subgraphs from the views of input space and latent space, respectively. The former is to capture the local structure of the graph, while the latter captures the long-range dependencies among nodes. By fusing these two views of subgraphs, the learned representations can preserve the topological properties of the graph at large, including the local structure and long-range dependencies, thus maximizing their expressiveness for downstream node classification tasks. Experimental results show that Muse outperforms the alternative methods on node classification tasks with limited labeled data.
4/22/2024