Efficient Imitation Learning with Conservative World Models
2405.13193
0
0
🌀
Abstract
We tackle the problem of policy learning from expert demonstrations without a reward function. A central challenge in this space is that these policies fail upon deployment due to issues of distributional shift, environment stochasticity, or compounding errors. Adversarial imitation learning alleviates this issue but requires additional on-policy training samples for stability, which presents a challenge in realistic domains due to inefficient learning and high sample complexity. One approach to this issue is to learn a world model of the environment, and use synthetic data for policy training. While successful in prior works, we argue that this is sub-optimal due to additional distribution shifts between the learned model and the real environment. Instead, we re-frame imitation learning as a fine-tuning problem, rather than a pure reinforcement learning one. Drawing theoretical connections to offline RL and fine-tuning algorithms, we argue that standard online world model algorithms are not well suited to the imitation learning problem. We derive a principled conservative optimization bound and demonstrate empirically that it leads to improved performance on two very challenging manipulation environments from high-dimensional raw pixel observations. We set a new state-of-the-art performance on the Franka Kitchen environment from images, requiring only 10 demos on no reward labels, as well as solving a complex dexterity manipulation task.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper tackles the challenge of learning policies from expert demonstrations without a reward function.
- The key issue is that these policies often fail when deployed due to distribution shift, stochasticity, or compounding errors.
- Adversarial imitation learning can help, but requires additional on-policy training samples which is costly.
- The authors propose reframing imitation learning as a fine-tuning problem rather than pure reinforcement learning.
Plain English Explanation
The researchers are working on a problem where they want to teach an AI system how to do a task by showing it examples of an expert doing the task, without providing a reward signal or score to indicate how well the system is performing. This is a common challenge in imitation learning.
The main issue is that the AI systems trained this way often fail when they are deployed and have to operate in the real world. This can happen because the training examples don't perfectly match the real-world conditions the system will face, leading to what's called "distributional shift." The system may also struggle with random changes in the environment or small errors building up over time.
One approach to this is adversarial imitation learning, which can help, but it requires gathering additional training samples while the system is operating, which can be very inefficient and costly, especially for complex real-world tasks.
Instead, the authors propose reframing the problem as a "fine-tuning" task, rather than pure reinforcement learning. This draws on ideas from offline reinforcement learning and transfer learning. They argue that standard techniques for learning world models, which has been successful in some prior work, aren't well-suited for this imitation learning problem.
Technical Explanation
The key technical contribution of this paper is a principled "conservative optimization" approach to imitation learning from expert demonstrations. The authors make connections to the offline reinforcement learning setting and show that standard online world model learning algorithms are sub-optimal for this problem.
Specifically, the authors derive a new optimization bound that encourages the learned policy to stay close to the demonstration data, rather than aggressively exploring the environment. They demonstrate empirically that this leads to improved performance on two challenging robotic manipulation tasks from raw pixel observations.
On the Franka Kitchen environment, the authors are able to achieve state-of-the-art results using only 10 demonstration examples, without any reward labels. They also solve a complex dexterity task that previous imitation learning approaches struggled with.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a compelling case for reframing imitation learning as a fine-tuning problem rather than pure reinforcement learning. The authors' theoretical analysis and empirical results highlight the shortcomings of standard world model learning techniques for this setting.
That said, the paper does not address some potential limitations. For example, the authors' approach still relies on access to a set of expert demonstrations, which may not always be available in practice. Additionally, the paper only evaluates the method on a limited set of environments, and it's unclear how well it would generalize to other domains.
Further research could explore ways to reduce the reliance on demonstration data, perhaps by incorporating reward modeling or other techniques. Expanding the evaluation to a broader range of tasks and settings would also help establish the broader applicability of the approach.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel perspective on imitation learning, reframing it as a fine-tuning problem rather than pure reinforcement learning. The authors' principled "conservative optimization" approach demonstrates strong empirical results on challenging robotic manipulation tasks, setting a new state-of-the-art on the Franka Kitchen environment.
While the paper has some limitations, it offers a valuable contribution to the imitation learning literature by highlighting the shortcomings of standard world model learning techniques and proposing a more effective alternative. This work could help pave the way for more robust and sample-efficient imitation learning systems that can reliably deploy in real-world settings.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Learning from Random Demonstrations: Offline Reinforcement Learning with Importance-Sampled Diffusion Models
Zeyu Fang, Tian Lan
0
0
Generative models such as diffusion have been employed as world models in offline reinforcement learning to generate synthetic data for more effective learning. Existing work either generates diffusion models one-time prior to training or requires additional interaction data to update it. In this paper, we propose a novel approach for offline reinforcement learning with closed-loop policy evaluation and world-model adaptation. It iteratively leverages a guided diffusion world model to directly evaluate the offline target policy with actions drawn from it, and then performs an importance-sampled world model update to adaptively align the world model with the updated policy. We analyzed the performance of the proposed method and provided an upper bound on the return gap between our method and the real environment under an optimal policy. The result sheds light on various factors affecting learning performance. Evaluations in the D4RL environment show significant improvement over state-of-the-art baselines, especially when only random or medium-expertise demonstrations are available -- thus requiring improved alignment between the world model and offline policy evaluation.
5/31/2024
Online Adaptation for Enhancing Imitation Learning Policies
Federico Malato, Ville Hautamaki
0
0
Imitation learning enables autonomous agents to learn from human examples, without the need for a reward signal. Still, if the provided dataset does not encapsulate the task correctly, or when the task is too complex to be modeled, such agents fail to reproduce the expert policy. We propose to recover from these failures through online adaptation. Our approach combines the action proposal coming from a pre-trained policy with relevant experience recorded by an expert. The combination results in an adapted action that closely follows the expert. Our experiments show that an adapted agent performs better than its pure imitation learning counterpart. Notably, adapted agents can achieve reasonable performance even when the base, non-adapted policy catastrophically fails.
6/10/2024
Hybrid Inverse Reinforcement Learning
Juntao Ren, Gokul Swamy, Zhiwei Steven Wu, J. Andrew Bagnell, Sanjiban Choudhury
0
0
The inverse reinforcement learning approach to imitation learning is a double-edged sword. On the one hand, it can enable learning from a smaller number of expert demonstrations with more robustness to error compounding than behavioral cloning approaches. On the other hand, it requires that the learner repeatedly solve a computationally expensive reinforcement learning (RL) problem. Often, much of this computation is wasted searching over policies very dissimilar to the expert's. In this work, we propose using hybrid RL -- training on a mixture of online and expert data -- to curtail unnecessary exploration. Intuitively, the expert data focuses the learner on good states during training, which reduces the amount of exploration required to compute a strong policy. Notably, such an approach doesn't need the ability to reset the learner to arbitrary states in the environment, a requirement of prior work in efficient inverse RL. More formally, we derive a reduction from inverse RL to expert-competitive RL (rather than globally optimal RL) that allows us to dramatically reduce interaction during the inner policy search loop while maintaining the benefits of the IRL approach. This allows us to derive both model-free and model-based hybrid inverse RL algorithms with strong policy performance guarantees. Empirically, we find that our approaches are significantly more sample efficient than standard inverse RL and several other baselines on a suite of continuous control tasks.
6/6/2024
Imitating Cost-Constrained Behaviors in Reinforcement Learning
Qian Shao, Pradeep Varakantham, Shih-Fen Cheng
0
0
Complex planning and scheduling problems have long been solved using various optimization or heuristic approaches. In recent years, imitation learning that aims to learn from expert demonstrations has been proposed as a viable alternative to solving these problems. Generally speaking, imitation learning is designed to learn either the reward (or preference) model or directly the behavioral policy by observing the behavior of an expert. Existing work in imitation learning and inverse reinforcement learning has focused on imitation primarily in unconstrained settings (e.g., no limit on fuel consumed by the vehicle). However, in many real-world domains, the behavior of an expert is governed not only by reward (or preference) but also by constraints. For instance, decisions on self-driving delivery vehicles are dependent not only on the route preferences/rewards (depending on past demand data) but also on the fuel in the vehicle and the time available. In such problems, imitation learning is challenging as decisions are not only dictated by the reward model but are also dependent on a cost-constrained model. In this paper, we provide multiple methods that match expert distributions in the presence of trajectory cost constraints through (a) Lagrangian-based method; (b) Meta-gradients to find a good trade-off between expected return and minimizing constraint violation; and (c) Cost-violation-based alternating gradient. We empirically show that leading imitation learning approaches imitate cost-constrained behaviors poorly and our meta-gradient-based approach achieves the best performance.
5/24/2024