Experimental Design for Active Transductive Inference in Large Language Models
2404.08846
0
0
Abstract
One emergent ability of large language models (LLMs) is that query-specific examples can be included in the prompt at inference time. In this work, we use active learning for adaptive prompt design and call it Active In-context Prompt Design (AIPD). We design the LLM prompt by adaptively choosing few-shot examples from a training set to optimize performance on a test set. The training examples are initially unlabeled and we obtain the label of the most informative ones, which maximally reduces uncertainty in the LLM prediction. We propose two algorithms, GO and SAL, which differ in how the few-shot examples are chosen. We analyze these algorithms in linear models: first GO and then use its equivalence with SAL. We experiment with many different tasks in small, medium-sized, and large language models; and show that GO and SAL outperform other methods for choosing few-shot examples in the LLM prompt at inference time.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents an experimental design for active transductive inference in large language models (LLMs).
- The authors investigate techniques for actively selecting the most informative data points to efficiently fine-tune or adapt LLMs to specific tasks or domains.
- The goal is to improve the performance and data efficiency of LLMs by strategically querying users or oracles for labels on selected inputs, rather than relying on full supervision.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) like GPT-3 have shown impressive capabilities, but they can be resource-intensive to train and may not perform well on specialized tasks or domains. This paper introduces techniques to more efficiently adapt LLMs to specific needs.
The key idea is to actively select the most informative data points to show to a human or "oracle" who can provide labels or annotations. This allows the model to learn from a smaller, more targeted set of examples, rather than requiring a large, fully labeled dataset. The authors call this "active transductive inference."
For example, if you wanted to fine-tune a language model to analyze legal documents, you might start by showing it a few examples and getting feedback. Based on the model's initial performance, you could strategically choose additional documents that would provide the most helpful information to improve its understanding of legal concepts and language. This is more efficient than showing the model a large corpus of legal texts all at once.
The goal is to make LLMs more adaptable and data-efficient, so they can be quickly customized for a wide range of applications without requiring massive amounts of labeled training data. This could be especially useful for tasks like personalized assistants or domain-specific language generation.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the active transductive inference problem and proposes several algorithms to solve it. The key steps are:
- Acquire Initial Model: Start with a pre-trained LLM, such as GPT-3.
- Acquire Unlabeled Data: Collect a pool of unlabeled data relevant to the target task or domain.
- Active Selection: Iteratively select the most informative data points from the pool to show to an oracle (e.g., a human annotator) and acquire labels.
- Model Adaptation: Use the selectively labeled data to fine-tune or adapt the initial LLM.
The authors propose several active selection strategies, including uncertainty sampling, expected model change, and Bayesian optimization. They evaluate these approaches on both synthetic and real-world language tasks, demonstrating significant improvements in data efficiency and task performance compared to fully supervised fine-tuning.
Critical Analysis
The proposed active transductive inference framework is a promising approach to improving the data efficiency and adaptability of large language models. By strategically querying for labels on informative data points, the model can learn more from fewer examples, which could be especially valuable for specialized or resource-constrained applications.
However, the authors acknowledge several limitations and areas for further research:
- The performance of the active selection strategies may be sensitive to the quality and consistency of the oracle feedback. Developing more robust techniques for handling noisy or biased annotations is an important next step.
- The experiments in the paper focus on relatively narrow language tasks. Evaluating the approach on a wider range of applications, including open-ended generation and multi-modal tasks, would help assess its broader applicability.
- The computational and storage overhead of the active selection process may limit its scalability to very large datasets or models. Further optimizations and approximations could make the technique more practical for real-world deployments.
Overall, this work provides a valuable contribution to the ongoing efforts to make large language models more flexible, efficient, and tailored to specific needs. Continued research in this direction could lead to significant advances in the field of adaptive and personalized AI systems.
Conclusion
This paper introduces an experimental design for active transductive inference, a technique to improve the data efficiency and adaptability of large language models. By strategically selecting the most informative data points to show to an oracle for labeling, the model can learn more from fewer examples, making it easier to fine-tune or customize the model for specific tasks or domains.
The proposed active selection algorithms demonstrate promising results on both synthetic and real-world language tasks, suggesting that this approach could be a valuable tool for developing more adaptable and efficient AI systems. As the authors note, further research is needed to address challenges like handling noisy annotations and scaling the techniques to larger datasets and models. But this work represents an important step forward in making large language models more flexible and tailored to diverse user needs.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
📉
Active Few-Shot Fine-Tuning
Jonas Hubotter, Bhavya Sukhija, Lenart Treven, Yarden As, Andreas Krause
0
0
We study the question: How can we select the right data for fine-tuning to a specific task? We call this data selection problem active fine-tuning and show that it is an instance of transductive active learning, a novel generalization of classical active learning. We propose ITL, short for information-based transductive learning, an approach which samples adaptively to maximize information gained about the specified task. We are the first to show, under general regularity assumptions, that such decision rules converge uniformly to the smallest possible uncertainty obtainable from the accessible data. We apply ITL to the few-shot fine-tuning of large neural networks and show that fine-tuning with ITL learns the task with significantly fewer examples than the state-of-the-art.
6/24/2024
💬
Active Prompting with Chain-of-Thought for Large Language Models
Shizhe Diao, Pengcheng Wang, Yong Lin, Tong Zhang
0
0
The increasing scale of large language models (LLMs) brings emergent abilities to various complex tasks requiring reasoning, such as arithmetic and commonsense reasoning. It is known that the effective design of task-specific prompts is critical for LLMs' ability to produce high-quality answers. In particular, an effective approach for complex question-and-answer tasks is example-based prompting with chain-of-thought (CoT) reasoning, which significantly improves the performance of LLMs. However, current CoT methods rely on a fixed set of human-annotated exemplars, which are not necessarily the most effective examples for different tasks. This paper proposes a new method, Active-Prompt, to adapt LLMs to different tasks with task-specific example prompts (annotated with human-designed CoT reasoning). For this purpose, we propose a solution to the key problem of determining which questions are the most important and helpful ones to annotate from a pool of task-specific queries. By borrowing ideas from the related problem of uncertainty-based active learning, we introduce several metrics to characterize the uncertainty so as to select the most uncertain questions for annotation. Experimental results demonstrate the superiority of our proposed method, achieving state-of-the-art on eight complex reasoning tasks. Further analyses of different uncertainty metrics, pool sizes, zero-shot learning, and accuracy-uncertainty relationship demonstrate the effectiveness of our method. Our code will be available at https://github.com/shizhediao/active-prompt.
6/10/2024
🌿
Transductive Active Learning: Theory and Applications
Jonas Hubotter, Bhavya Sukhija, Lenart Treven, Yarden As, Andreas Krause
0
0
We generalize active learning to address real-world settings with concrete prediction targets where sampling is restricted to an accessible region of the domain, while prediction targets may lie outside this region. We analyze a family of decision rules that sample adaptively to minimize uncertainty about prediction targets. We are the first to show, under general regularity assumptions, that such decision rules converge uniformly to the smallest possible uncertainty obtainable from the accessible data. We demonstrate their strong sample efficiency in two key applications: Active few-shot fine-tuning of large neural networks and safe Bayesian optimization, where they improve significantly upon the state-of-the-art.
5/24/2024
Active Preference Inference using Language Models and Probabilistic Reasoning
Wasu Top Piriyakulkij, Volodymyr Kuleshov, Kevin Ellis
0
0
Actively inferring user preferences, for example by asking good questions, is important for any human-facing decision-making system. Active inference allows such systems to adapt and personalize themselves to nuanced individual preferences. To enable this ability for instruction-tuned large language models (LLMs), one may prompt them to ask users questions to infer their preferences, transforming the language models into more robust, interactive systems. However, out of the box, these models are not efficient at extracting preferences: the questions they generate are not informative, requiring a high number of user interactions and impeding the usability of the downstream system. In this work, we introduce an inference-time algorithm that helps LLMs quickly infer preferences by using more informative questions. Our algorithm uses a probabilistic model whose conditional distributions are defined by prompting an LLM, and returns questions that optimize expected entropy and expected model change. Results in a simplified interactive web shopping setting with real product items show that an LLM equipped with our entropy reduction algorithm outperforms baselines with the same underlying LLM on task performance while using fewer user interactions.
6/27/2024