Fishing for Magikarp: Automatically Detecting Under-trained Tokens in Large Language Models
127
💬
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- The paper discusses the issue of "glitch tokens" in large language models (LLMs), which are tokens that are present in the tokenizer vocabulary but are nearly or fully absent from the training data.
- These problematic tokens can induce unwanted behavior in LLMs, as seen with the infamous "SolidGoldMagikarp" token.
- The researchers present a comprehensive analysis of LLM tokenizers, aiming to develop effective methods for automatically detecting these under-trained tokens.
Plain English Explanation
Large language models like GPT-3 are trained on vast amounts of text data to become highly capable at tasks like language generation and understanding. However, the process of creating the tokenizer - the system that converts text into the numerical inputs the model understands - can sometimes lead to issues.
One problem is the existence of "glitch tokens," which are rare or nonsensical words that make it into the tokenizer's vocabulary, but are hardly ever seen in the actual training data. This can cause the model to behave unexpectedly when faced with these tokens, like the infamous "SolidGoldMagikarp" example.
To address this, the researchers in this paper aimed to develop reliable ways to identify these problematic tokens. They analyzed the tokenizers and model weights of various large language models, as well as tried different prompting techniques, to find effective methods for detecting under-trained tokens. Their findings suggest that this issue is quite prevalent across many different models, and they provide insights on how to make language models more efficient and safer.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents a comprehensive analysis of LLM tokenizers and their tendency to include "glitch tokens" - tokens that are present in the tokenizer vocabulary but are nearly or fully absent from the model's training data.
The researchers combined several approaches to detect these problematic tokens:
- Tokenizer analysis: Examining the tokenizer's vocabulary and identifying tokens with low training corpus frequency.
- Model weight-based indicators: Analyzing the model's weight matrices to find tokens with anomalous representations.
- Prompting techniques: Designing specialized prompts to trigger unwanted behavior from the model when using suspect tokens.
Through this multi-faceted approach, the researchers were able to effectively identify glitch tokens across a variety of large language models. Their findings demonstrate the prevalence of this issue and provide insights that can help improve the efficiency and safety of LLMs.
Critical Analysis
The researchers acknowledge that their methods for detecting glitch tokens, while effective, are not exhaustive. There may be other types of problematic tokens or edge cases that their approach does not capture. Additionally, the paper does not delve into the underlying causes of these glitch tokens or propose comprehensive solutions to prevent their occurrence in the first place.
Further research is needed to fully understand the process of tokenization in LLMs and develop more robust techniques for ensuring the integrity of the tokenizer vocabulary. The paper also does not address potential issues of linguistic discrimination that could arise from the presence of glitch tokens, which is an important consideration for the responsible development of these models.
Conclusion
This paper highlights a critical issue in the development of large language models - the presence of "glitch tokens" that can induce unwanted behavior. By combining various analysis methods, the researchers have developed effective techniques for detecting these problematic tokens across different LLMs.
Their findings shed light on the importance of thoroughly examining the tokenization process and model weights to ensure the safety and reliability of these powerful AI systems. As the field of large language model research continues to advance, addressing issues like glitch tokens will be crucial for building language models that are not only highly capable, but also trustworthy and aligned with societal values.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
💬
127
Fishing for Magikarp: Automatically Detecting Under-trained Tokens in Large Language Models
Sander Land, Max Bartolo
The disconnect between tokenizer creation and model training in language models has been known to allow for certain inputs, such as the infamous SolidGoldMagikarp token, to induce unwanted behaviour. Although such `glitch tokens' that are present in the tokenizer vocabulary, but are nearly or fully absent in training, have been observed across a variety of different models, a consistent way of identifying them has been missing. We present a comprehensive analysis of Large Language Model (LLM) tokenizers, specifically targeting this issue of detecting untrained and under-trained tokens. Through a combination of tokenizer analysis, model weight-based indicators, and prompting techniques, we develop effective methods for automatically detecting these problematic tokens. Our findings demonstrate the prevalence of such tokens across various models and provide insights into improving the efficiency and safety of language models.
Read more5/10/2024
💬
0
Glitch Tokens in Large Language Models: Categorization Taxonomy and Effective Detection
Yuxi Li, Yi Liu, Gelei Deng, Ying Zhang, Wenjia Song, Ling Shi, Kailong Wang, Yuekang Li, Yang Liu, Haoyu Wang
With the expanding application of Large Language Models (LLMs) in various domains, it becomes imperative to comprehensively investigate their unforeseen behaviors and consequent outcomes. In this study, we introduce and systematically explore the phenomenon of glitch tokens, which are anomalous tokens produced by established tokenizers and could potentially compromise the models' quality of response. Specifically, we experiment on seven top popular LLMs utilizing three distinct tokenizers and involving a totally of 182,517 tokens. We present categorizations of the identified glitch tokens and symptoms exhibited by LLMs when interacting with glitch tokens. Based on our observation that glitch tokens tend to cluster in the embedding space, we propose GlitchHunter, a novel iterative clustering-based technique, for efficient glitch token detection. The evaluation shows that our approach notably outperforms three baseline methods on eight open-source LLMs. To the best of our knowledge, we present the first comprehensive study on glitch tokens. Our new detection further provides valuable insights into mitigating tokenization-related errors in LLMs.
Read more4/22/2024
0
GlitchProber: Advancing Effective Detection and Mitigation of Glitch Tokens in Large Language Models
Zhibo Zhang, Wuxia Bai, Yuxi Li, Mark Huasong Meng, Kailong Wang, Ling Shi, Li Li, Jun Wang, Haoyu Wang
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved unprecedented success in the field of natural language processing. However, the black-box nature of their internal mechanisms has brought many concerns about their trustworthiness and interpretability. Recent research has discovered a class of abnormal tokens in the model's vocabulary space and named them glitch tokens. Those tokens, once included in the input, may induce the model to produce incorrect, irrelevant, or even harmful results, drastically undermining the reliability and practicality of LLMs. In this work, we aim to enhance the understanding of glitch tokens and propose techniques for their detection and mitigation. We first reveal the characteristic features induced by glitch tokens on LLMs, which are evidenced by significant deviations in the distributions of attention patterns and dynamic information from intermediate model layers. Based on the insights, we develop GlitchProber, a tool for efficient glitch token detection and mitigation. GlitchProber utilizes small-scale sampling, principal component analysis for accelerated feature extraction, and a simple classifier for efficient vocabulary screening. Taking one step further, GlitchProber rectifies abnormal model intermediate layer values to mitigate the destructive effects of glitch tokens. Evaluated on five mainstream open-source LLMs, GlitchProber demonstrates higher efficiency, precision, and recall compared to existing approaches, with an average F1 score of 0.86 and an average repair rate of 50.06%. GlitchProber unveils a novel path to address the challenges posed by glitch tokens and inspires future research toward more robust and interpretable LLMs.
Read more8/12/2024
0
Adaptive Pre-training Data Detection for Large Language Models via Surprising Tokens
Anqi Zhang, Chaofeng Wu
While large language models (LLMs) are extensively used, there are raising concerns regarding privacy, security, and copyright due to their opaque training data, which brings the problem of detecting pre-training data on the table. Current solutions to this problem leverage techniques explored in machine learning privacy such as Membership Inference Attacks (MIAs), which heavily depend on LLMs' capability of verbatim memorization. However, this reliance presents challenges, especially given the vast amount of training data and the restricted number of effective training epochs. In this paper, we propose an adaptive pre-training data detection method which alleviates this reliance and effectively amplify the identification. Our method adaptively locates textit{surprising tokens} of the input. A token is surprising to a LLM if the prediction on the token is certain but wrong, which refers to low Shannon entropy of the probability distribution and low probability of the ground truth token at the same time. By using the prediction probability of surprising tokens to measure textit{surprising}, the detection method is achieved based on the simple hypothesis that seeing seen data is less surprising for the model compared with seeing unseen data. The method can be applied without any access to the the pre-training data corpus or additional training like reference models. Our approach exhibits a consistent enhancement compared to existing methods in diverse experiments conducted on various benchmarks and models, achieving a maximum improvement of 29.5%. We also introduce a new benchmark Dolma-Book developed upon a novel framework, which employs book data collected both before and after model training to provide further evaluation.
Read more8/1/2024