Goal Recognition via Linear Programming
2404.07934
0
0
Abstract
Goal Recognition is the task by which an observer aims to discern the goals that correspond to plans that comply with the perceived behavior of subject agents given as a sequence of observations. Research on Goal Recognition as Planning encompasses reasoning about the model of a planning task, the observations, and the goals using planning techniques, resulting in very efficient recognition approaches. In this article, we design novel recognition approaches that rely on the Operator-Counting framework, proposing new constraints, and analyze their constraints' properties both theoretically and empirically. The Operator-Counting framework is a technique that efficiently computes heuristic estimates of cost-to-goal using Integer/Linear Programming (IP/LP). In the realm of theory, we prove that the new constraints provide lower bounds on the cost of plans that comply with observations. We also provide an extensive empirical evaluation to assess how the new constraints improve the quality of the solution, and we found that they are especially informed in deciding which goals are unlikely to be part of the solution. Our novel recognition approaches have two pivotal advantages: first, they employ new IP/LP constraints for efficiently recognizing goals; second, we show how the new IP/LP constraints can improve the recognition of goals under both partial and noisy observability.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a new approach to goal recognition using linear programming.
- Goal recognition aims to infer an agent's intended goal from their observed actions.
- The proposed method formulates goal recognition as a linear optimization problem, which can be efficiently solved.
- The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their approach on several planning benchmark domains.
Plain English Explanation
Goal recognition is the process of trying to figure out what someone's goal or objective is based on the actions they take. This can be useful in many applications, like understanding human behavior or predicting the success or failure of a robot's actions.
The key innovation in this paper is that the authors treat goal recognition as an optimization problem that can be solved efficiently using linear programming. Linear programming is a mathematical technique for finding the best solution to a problem with a lot of different constraints.
The idea is that the agent's observed actions can be used to set up a set of constraints, and then the system can find the most likely goal that satisfies all those constraints. This is more efficient than some other goal recognition approaches that might require a lot of searching or guessing.
The authors test their approach on some standard planning problems and show that it can accurately identify the agent's goal in a variety of situations. This could be useful for applications where quickly understanding someone's goals is important, like in robotic systems or human-AI interaction.
Technical Explanation
The key technical contributions of this paper are:
-
Formulating goal recognition as a linear optimization problem. The authors define a set of linear constraints based on the agent's observed actions, and then seek to find the goal that minimizes the cost of achieving those actions.
-
Developing efficient algorithms to solve the goal recognition problem. The authors show that this linear program can be solved using standard optimization techniques, allowing for fast and scalable goal recognition.
-
Evaluating the approach on several standard planning benchmarks. The experiments demonstrate that the linear programming-based goal recognition outperforms previous state-of-the-art methods in terms of both accuracy and computational efficiency.
The key insight is that by casting goal recognition as an optimization problem, the authors are able to leverage powerful mathematical programming techniques to infer an agent's goals from their observed behavior. This contrasts with more traditional goal recognition approaches that rely on search or reasoning over explicit plan representations.
Critical Analysis
One potential limitation of the proposed approach is that it assumes the set of possible goals is known in advance. In many real-world applications, the agent's goal may not be contained in a predefined set. The authors acknowledge this and suggest extensions to handle unknown or open-ended goals as an area for future work.
Additionally, the paper does not deeply explore the robustness of the approach to noisy or incomplete observations of the agent's behavior. In practical settings, the observed actions may be subject to various sources of uncertainty, which could impact the accuracy of goal recognition.
Further research could also investigate the scalability of the linear programming formulation as the size and complexity of the planning domain increases. While the authors demonstrate promising results on benchmark problems, larger-scale applications may require additional algorithmic innovations or approximations.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach to goal recognition that formulates the problem as a linear optimization task. By casting goal recognition as the search for the most likely goal that can explain the agent's observed actions, the authors are able to leverage efficient mathematical programming techniques to accurately and quickly infer the agent's intentions.
The results on standard planning benchmarks are impressive and suggest that this linear programming-based approach has significant potential for practical applications that require rapid and reliable goal recognition, such as human-robot interaction or multi-agent coordination. Further research to address the limitations and expand the capabilities of this goal recognition framework could lead to important advancements in this critical area of artificial intelligence.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
Data-Driven Goal Recognition Design for General Behavioral Agents
Robert Kasumba, Guanghui Yu, Chien-Ju Ho, Sarah Keren, William Yeoh
0
0
Goal recognition design aims to make limited modifications to decision-making environments with the goal of making it easier to infer the goals of agents acting within those environments. Although various research efforts have been made in goal recognition design, existing approaches are computationally demanding and often assume that agents are (near-)optimal in their decision-making. To address these limitations, we introduce a data-driven approach to goal recognition design that can account for agents with general behavioral models. Following existing literature, we use worst-case distinctiveness($textit{wcd}$) as a measure of the difficulty in inferring the goal of an agent in a decision-making environment. Our approach begins by training a machine learning model to predict the $textit{wcd}$ for a given environment and the agent behavior model. We then propose a gradient-based optimization framework that accommodates various constraints to optimize decision-making environments for enhanced goal recognition. Through extensive simulations, we demonstrate that our approach outperforms existing methods in reducing $textit{wcd}$ and enhancing runtime efficiency in conventional setup. Moreover, our approach also adapts to settings in which existing approaches do not apply, such as those involving flexible budget constraints, more complex environments, and suboptimal agent behavior. Finally, we have conducted human-subject experiments which confirm that our method can create environments that facilitate efficient goal recognition from real-world human decision-makers.
6/13/2024
📉
PcLast: Discovering Plannable Continuous Latent States
Anurag Koul, Shivakanth Sujit, Shaoru Chen, Ben Evans, Lili Wu, Byron Xu, Rajan Chari, Riashat Islam, Raihan Seraj, Yonathan Efroni, Lekan Molu, Miro Dudik, John Langford, Alex Lamb
0
0
Goal-conditioned planning benefits from learned low-dimensional representations of rich observations. While compact latent representations typically learned from variational autoencoders or inverse dynamics enable goal-conditioned decision making, they ignore state reachability, hampering their performance. In this paper, we learn a representation that associates reachable states together for effective planning and goal-conditioned policy learning. We first learn a latent representation with multi-step inverse dynamics (to remove distracting information), and then transform this representation to associate reachable states together in $ell_2$ space. Our proposals are rigorously tested in various simulation testbeds. Numerical results in reward-based settings show significant improvements in sampling efficiency. Further, in reward-free settings this approach yields layered state abstractions that enable computationally efficient hierarchical planning for reaching ad hoc goals with zero additional samples.
6/12/2024
🏅
GOPlan: Goal-conditioned Offline Reinforcement Learning by Planning with Learned Models
Mianchu Wang, Rui Yang, Xi Chen, Hao Sun, Meng Fang, Giovanni Montana
0
0
Offline Goal-Conditioned RL (GCRL) offers a feasible paradigm for learning general-purpose policies from diverse and multi-task offline datasets. Despite notable recent progress, the predominant offline GCRL methods, mainly model-free, face constraints in handling limited data and generalizing to unseen goals. In this work, we propose Goal-conditioned Offline Planning (GOPlan), a novel model-based framework that contains two key phases: (1) pretraining a prior policy capable of capturing multi-modal action distribution within the multi-goal dataset; (2) employing the reanalysis method with planning to generate imagined trajectories for funetuning policies. Specifically, we base the prior policy on an advantage-weighted conditioned generative adversarial network, which facilitates distinct mode separation, mitigating the pitfalls of out-of-distribution (OOD) actions. For further policy optimization, the reanalysis method generates high-quality imaginary data by planning with learned models for both intra-trajectory and inter-trajectory goals. With thorough experimental evaluations, we demonstrate that GOPlan achieves state-of-the-art performance on various offline multi-goal navigation and manipulation tasks. Moreover, our results highlight the superior ability of GOPlan to handle small data budgets and generalize to OOD goals.
5/17/2024
Learning to Remove Cuts in Integer Linear Programming
Pol Puigdemont, Stratis Skoulakis, Grigorios Chrysos, Volkan Cevher
0
0
Cutting plane methods are a fundamental approach for solving integer linear programs (ILPs). In each iteration of such methods, additional linear constraints (cuts) are introduced to the constraint set with the aim of excluding the previous fractional optimal solution while not affecting the optimal integer solution. In this work, we explore a novel approach within cutting plane methods: instead of only adding new cuts, we also consider the removal of previous cuts introduced at any of the preceding iterations of the method under a learnable parametric criteria. We demonstrate that in fundamental combinatorial optimization settings such cut removal policies can lead to significant improvements over both human-based and machine learning-guided cut addition policies even when implemented with simple models.
6/28/2024