Illusory Attacks: Detectability Matters in Adversarial Attacks on Sequential Decision-Makers

Overview

• Autonomous agents deployed in the real world need to be robust against adversarial attacks on their sensory inputs.
• Existing observation-space attacks on reinforcement learning agents are effective but lack information-theoretic detectability constraints, making them detectable using automated means or human inspection.
• The paper introduces eattacks{}, a novel form of adversarial attack that is both effective and of ε-bounded statistical detectability.
• The authors propose a novel dual ascent algorithm to learn such attacks end-to-end and empirically find eattacks{} to be significantly harder to detect with automated methods and human participants.

Plain English Explanation

Autonomous agents, like self-driving cars or robots, need to be able to handle unexpected or malicious inputs that could try to trick them. The paper looks at a type of attack called an "observation-space attack," where an adversary tries to manipulate the sensor inputs of the agent to make it behave in a way that is harmful or undesirable.

The key insight is that while these existing attacks are effective, they have a weakness: they can be easily detected, either by automated systems or by humans inspecting the agent's behavior. This is problematic for the adversary because if their attack is detected, it could trigger security measures or other responses that they want to avoid.

To address this, the researchers introduce a new type of attack called eattacks{}. These attacks are designed to be both effective at manipulating the agent's behavior and also very difficult to detect, even with advanced methods. The key is that eattacks{} have a strict limit on how statistically different they are from normal, non-adversarial inputs.

The researchers develop a novel algorithm to learn these eattacks{} and show through experiments that they are indeed much harder to detect than existing attacks, both through automated systems and with human participants. This suggests that we need better ways to detect and defend against these types of stealthy adversarial attacks, as they could pose a significant threat to the safety and reliability of autonomous systems deployed in the real world.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes a novel form of adversarial attack called eattacks{} that is both effective at manipulating the behavior of reinforcement learning agents and has ε-bounded statistical detectability. This is in contrast to existing observation-space attacks, which the authors find lack such detectability constraints, making them more easily identifiable.

The authors develop a dual ascent algorithm to learn these eattacks{} end-to-end. The core idea is to optimize the attack to maximize its effectiveness at fooling the agent, while simultaneously minimizing a statistical distance metric that captures the attack's detectability. This ensures the learned attacks are both potent and stealthy.

Through extensive experiments, the researchers demonstrate that eattacks{} are significantly harder to detect using automated anomaly detection methods compared to previous attack approaches. Additionally, a small user study with human participants suggests that eattacks{} are also more challenging for people to identify as adversarial.

The authors argue that these findings highlight the need for better anomaly detectors and more robust hardware- and system-level defenses against such stealthy adversarial attacks, as they pose a serious threat to the reliability and safety of autonomous agents deployed in the real world.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a valuable contribution by introducing the concept of ε-bounded statistical detectability for adversarial attacks, which addresses a key weakness in existing observation-space attacks. By optimizing for both effectiveness and stealthiness, the eattacks{} approach represents an important advancement in the field of adversarial machine learning.

However, the user study with human participants was quite small in scale, with only 20 participants. While the results suggest eattacks{} are harder for humans to detect, a larger-scale study would be needed to draw more definitive conclusions. Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity or scalability of the dual ascent algorithm used to generate the eattacks{}, which could be an important practical consideration.

Further research could explore the generalizability of the eattacks{} approach to a wider range of reinforcement learning agents and environments, as well as investigate potential defenses that go beyond just anomaly detection, such as structural adversarial attacks or resilient adversarial detectors. There may also be opportunities to further study the human evaluation of such attacks and develop more robust approaches to assessing their impact.

Overall, this paper represents an important step forward in understanding and addressing the vulnerabilities of autonomous agents to sophisticated adversarial attacks, and highlights the need for continued research and development of effective defenses.

Conclusion

The paper introduces a novel form of adversarial attack called eattacks{} that is both effective at manipulating the behavior of reinforcement learning agents and has ε-bounded statistical detectability. This addresses a key weakness in existing observation-space attacks, which can be more easily identified through automated or human-based detection methods.

The researchers develop a dual ascent algorithm to learn these eattacks{} end-to-end, and their experiments demonstrate that the resulting attacks are significantly harder to detect than previous approaches, both through automated anomaly detection and with human participants. This suggests the need for better anomaly detectors and more robust hardware- and system-level defenses to protect autonomous agents deployed in the real world against such stealthy adversarial attacks.

The findings of this work highlight the ongoing challenges in building truly reliable and secure autonomous systems, and the importance of continued research and development in this critical area of study.