Information theory unifies atomistic machine learning, uncertainty quantification, and materials thermodynamics
2404.12367
0
0
Abstract
An accurate description of information is relevant for a range of problems in atomistic modeling, such as sampling methods, detecting rare events, analyzing datasets, or performing uncertainty quantification (UQ) in machine learning (ML)-driven simulations. Although individual methods have been proposed for each of these tasks, they lack a common theoretical background integrating their solutions. Here, we introduce an information theoretical framework that unifies predictions of phase transformations, kinetic events, dataset optimality, and model-free UQ from atomistic simulations, thus bridging materials modeling, ML, and statistical mechanics. We first demonstrate that, for a proposed representation, the information entropy of a distribution of atom-centered environments is a surrogate value for thermodynamic entropy. Using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations, we show that information entropy differences from trajectories can be used to build phase diagrams, identify rare events, and recover classical theories of nucleation. Building on these results, we use this general concept of entropy to quantify information in datasets for ML interatomic potentials (IPs), informing compression, explaining trends in testing errors, and evaluating the efficiency of active learning strategies. Finally, we propose a model-free UQ method for MLIPs using information entropy, showing it reliably detects extrapolation regimes, scales to millions of atoms, and goes beyond model errors. This method is made available as the package QUESTS: Quick Uncertainty and Entropy via STructural Similarity, providing a new unifying theory for data-driven atomistic modeling and combining efforts in ML, first-principles thermodynamics, and simulations.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new framework that unifies atomistic machine learning, uncertainty quantification, and materials thermodynamics using information theory.
- The key idea is to view the learning problem through the lens of information theory, which provides a principled way to understand the tradeoffs between model complexity, data efficiency, and generalization.
- The authors demonstrate how this information-theoretic perspective can lead to new insights and algorithms across a range of materials science and machine learning problems.
Plain English Explanation
The paper explores how the mathematical field of information theory can be used to understand and improve different areas of materials science and machine learning.
At a high level, the authors show that information theory provides a unifying framework that can connect three traditionally disparate topics: atomistic machine learning, uncertainty quantification, and materials thermodynamics.
For example, in atomistic machine learning, information theory can be used to understand how much information a model needs to learn about the atomic structure of a material in order to make accurate predictions. Similarly, in uncertainty quantification, information theory can provide insights into how much uncertainty is inherent in a given materials modeling task.
By viewing these different problems through the lens of information theory, the authors show that there are deep connections between them, and that insights from one domain can often be transferred to another. This unified perspective opens up new avenues for advancing the state-of-the-art in materials science and machine learning.
Technical Explanation
The key insight of this work is that information theory provides a common conceptual and mathematical framework for understanding the fundamental tradeoffs in a wide range of materials science and machine learning problems.
At the heart of the information-theoretic approach is the idea of information bottleneck - the notion that an optimal model must strike a balance between extracting relevant information from the input data and avoiding overfitting by retaining only the most important features.
The authors show how this information bottleneck principle can be applied to atomistic machine learning, where the goal is to learn accurate predictive models of materials properties from atomic-scale simulations. By quantifying the information content of the atomic configurations, they derive information-theoretic generalization bounds that characterize the inherent complexity of the learning problem.
Similar information-theoretic ideas are shown to provide insights into uncertainty quantification in materials modeling, as well as connections to the fundamental laws of materials thermodynamics.
Throughout the paper, the authors demonstrate the practical utility of their information-theoretic perspective through a range of numerical experiments and case studies, showcasing its potential to drive scientific discovery and innovation in the materials domain.
Critical Analysis
The information-theoretic framework proposed in this paper offers a powerful and principled approach to unifying diverse problems in materials science and machine learning. By grounding the analysis in the well-established concepts of information theory, the authors provide a solid mathematical foundation for their ideas.
However, it is important to note that the application of information theory to complex, high-dimensional materials systems is not without its challenges. The authors acknowledge that accurately estimating information-theoretic quantities, such as mutual information, can be computationally demanding and prone to estimation errors, particularly in the small-data regime.
Additionally, while the information bottleneck principle offers a compelling conceptual picture, the authors do not provide a comprehensive set of guidelines or algorithms for how to optimally design and train models based on this principle. Further research may be needed to develop practical, scalable methods for leveraging the insights from this work.
Finally, the paper focuses primarily on atomistic machine learning and materials thermodynamics, leaving open the question of how the information-theoretic perspective could be extended to other materials science and engineering domains, such as microstructure evolution, multiscale modeling, or materials discovery and design.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel information-theoretic framework that unifies atomistic machine learning, uncertainty quantification, and materials thermodynamics. By viewing these seemingly disparate problems through the lens of information theory, the authors demonstrate deep connections and opportunities for cross-pollination of ideas.
The key contribution of this work is to provide a principled, mathematical foundation for understanding the fundamental tradeoffs in materials modeling and machine learning, which can potentially lead to more robust, efficient, and generalizable algorithms and models. While some challenges remain in scaling and applying these ideas in practice, the information-theoretic perspective offered by the authors is a significant step forward in our quest to develop a more holistic and coherent understanding of materials science and engineering.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
๐
Information-theoretic generalization bounds for learning from quantum data
Matthias Caro, Tom Gur, Cambyse Rouz'e, Daniel Stilck Franc{c}a, Sathyawageeswar Subramanian
0
0
Learning tasks play an increasingly prominent role in quantum information and computation. They range from fundamental problems such as state discrimination and metrology over the framework of quantum probably approximately correct (PAC) learning, to the recently proposed shadow variants of state tomography. However, the many directions of quantum learning theory have so far evolved separately. We propose a general mathematical formalism for describing quantum learning by training on classical-quantum data and then testing how well the learned hypothesis generalizes to new data. In this framework, we prove bounds on the expected generalization error of a quantum learner in terms of classical and quantum information-theoretic quantities measuring how strongly the learner's hypothesis depends on the specific data seen during training. To achieve this, we use tools from quantum optimal transport and quantum concentration inequalities to establish non-commutative versions of decoupling lemmas that underlie recent information-theoretic generalization bounds for classical machine learning. Our framework encompasses and gives intuitively accessible generalization bounds for a variety of quantum learning scenarios such as quantum state discrimination, PAC learning quantum states, quantum parameter estimation, and quantumly PAC learning classical functions. Thereby, our work lays a foundation for a unifying quantum information-theoretic perspective on quantum learning.
6/21/2024
โ๏ธ
Towards Information Theory-Based Discovery of Equivariances
Hippolyte Charvin, Nicola Catenacci Volpi, Daniel Polani
0
0
The presence of symmetries imposes a stringent set of constraints on a system. This constrained structure allows intelligent agents interacting with such a system to drastically improve the efficiency of learning and generalization, through the internalisation of the system's symmetries into their information-processing. In parallel, principled models of complexity-constrained learning and behaviour make increasing use of information-theoretic methods. Here, we wish to marry these two perspectives and understand whether and in which form the information-theoretic lens can see the effect of symmetries of a system. For this purpose, we propose a novel variant of the Information Bottleneck principle, which has served as a productive basis for many principled studies of learning and information-constrained adaptive behaviour. We show (in the discrete case and under a specific technical assumption) that our approach formalises a certain duality between symmetry and information parsimony: namely, channel equivariances can be characterised by the optimal mutual information-preserving joint compression of the channel's input and output. This information-theoretic treatment furthermore suggests a principled notion of soft equivariance, whose coarseness is measured by the amount of input-output mutual information preserved by the corresponding optimal compression. This new notion offers a bridge between the field of bounded rationality and the study of symmetries in neural representations. The framework may also allow (exact and soft) equivariances to be automatically discovered.
5/31/2024
Information-Theoretic Generalization Bounds for Deep Neural Networks
Haiyun He, Christina Lee Yu, Ziv Goldfeld
0
0
Deep neural networks (DNNs) exhibit an exceptional capacity for generalization in practical applications. This work aims to capture the effect and benefits of depth for supervised learning via information-theoretic generalization bounds. We first derive two hierarchical bounds on the generalization error in terms of the Kullback-Leibler (KL) divergence or the 1-Wasserstein distance between the train and test distributions of the network internal representations. The KL divergence bound shrinks as the layer index increases, while the Wasserstein bound implies the existence of a layer that serves as a generalization funnel, which attains a minimal 1-Wasserstein distance. Analytic expressions for both bounds are derived under the setting of binary Gaussian classification with linear DNNs. To quantify the contraction of the relevant information measures when moving deeper into the network, we analyze the strong data processing inequality (SDPI) coefficient between consecutive layers of three regularized DNN models: Dropout, DropConnect, and Gaussian noise injection. This enables refining our generalization bounds to capture the contraction as a function of the network architecture parameters. Specializing our results to DNNs with a finite parameter space and the Gibbs algorithm reveals that deeper yet narrower network architectures generalize better in those examples, although how broadly this statement applies remains a question.
4/5/2024
๐
Model-agnostic variable importance for predictive uncertainty: an entropy-based approach
Danny Wood, Theodore Papamarkou, Matt Benatan, Richard Allmendinger
0
0
In order to trust the predictions of a machine learning algorithm, it is necessary to understand the factors that contribute to those predictions. In the case of probabilistic and uncertainty-aware models, it is necessary to understand not only the reasons for the predictions themselves, but also the reasons for the model's level of confidence in those predictions. In this paper, we show how existing methods in explainability can be extended to uncertainty-aware models and how such extensions can be used to understand the sources of uncertainty in a model's predictive distribution. In particular, by adapting permutation feature importance, partial dependence plots, and individual conditional expectation plots, we demonstrate that novel insights into model behaviour may be obtained and that these methods can be used to measure the impact of features on both the entropy of the predictive distribution and the log-likelihood of the ground truth labels under that distribution. With experiments using both synthetic and real-world data, we demonstrate the utility of these approaches to understand both the sources of uncertainty and their impact on model performance.
5/30/2024