KTbench: A Novel Data Leakage-Free Framework for Knowledge Tracing
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- Introduces a novel data leakage-free framework called KTbench for evaluating knowledge tracing models
- Highlights the importance of addressing data leakage issues in benchmark datasets for knowledge tracing
- Presents a comprehensive analysis of data leakage in existing knowledge tracing datasets and proposes solutions to mitigate these issues
Plain English Explanation
Knowledge tracing is a technique used in intelligent tutoring systems to model a student's understanding of different concepts over time. Accurate knowledge tracing is crucial for providing personalized learning experiences and identifying areas where students need more support.
However, many existing benchmark datasets used to evaluate knowledge tracing models suffer from data leakage issues, where information about future student performance is inadvertently revealed in the training data. This can lead to overly optimistic model performance and prevent the development of truly robust and generalizable knowledge tracing systems.
The authors of this paper introduce KTbench, a new framework that addresses these data leakage problems. KTbench includes a set of curated datasets and evaluation protocols designed to ensure a fair and realistic assessment of knowledge tracing models. The framework also provides tools and guidelines for researchers to identify and mitigate data leakage in their own datasets and experiments.
By using KTbench, researchers can develop more reliable and trustworthy knowledge tracing models that can better support personalized learning and improve educational outcomes.
Technical Explanation
The paper presents KTbench, a novel framework for evaluating knowledge tracing models in a data leakage-free manner. The authors first conduct a comprehensive analysis of data leakage issues in existing knowledge tracing datasets, such as ASSIST, ASSISTments, and EdNet. They identify several sources of data leakage, including information about future performance being encoded in the item metadata, as well as temporal dependencies between training and test samples.
To address these issues, the authors curate a new set of datasets and define evaluation protocols that ensure a fair and realistic assessment of knowledge tracing models. The KTbench framework includes features such as:
- Strict temporal split of training and test data to prevent information leakage
- Rigorous item metadata scrubbing to remove any potential sources of leakage
- Comprehensive dataset statistics and visualization tools to aid in the identification of data leakage
The paper also presents a set of baseline knowledge tracing models, including DKT, SAKT, and SAINT, evaluated on the KTbench datasets. The results show a significant performance gap between the models' performance on the original datasets and the KTbench datasets, highlighting the importance of addressing data leakage for reliable model evaluation.
Critical Analysis
The authors of the paper have done an excellent job in identifying and addressing the critical issue of data leakage in knowledge tracing benchmark datasets. By providing a robust and comprehensive framework like KTbench, they have opened up new avenues for the development of more reliable and generalizable knowledge tracing models.
However, one potential limitation of the KTbench framework is that it may not capture all possible sources of data leakage, as the authors acknowledge. There could be other subtle or complex patterns in the data that could still lead to information leakage, even with the proposed mitigations. Additionally, the KTbench datasets may not be representative of all possible educational scenarios, and further validation on a wider range of datasets would be beneficial.
Another area for further research could be the development of more advanced techniques for identifying and mitigating data leakage in knowledge tracing data. The current approach relies on manual curation and statistical analysis, which may not scale well to larger and more complex datasets.
Overall, the KTbench framework represents a significant contribution to the field of knowledge tracing and intelligent tutoring systems. By addressing the data leakage issue, the authors have paved the way for more robust and trustworthy models that can have a real impact on educational outcomes.
Conclusion
The KTbench framework introduced in this paper is a crucial step towards addressing the data leakage problem in knowledge tracing benchmark datasets. By providing a set of curated datasets and evaluation protocols that ensure a fair and realistic assessment of knowledge tracing models, the authors have laid the foundation for the development of more reliable and generalizable models.
The insights and solutions presented in this paper have the potential to benefit a wide range of stakeholders, from educational researchers and practitioners to developers of intelligent tutoring systems. By using KTbench, researchers can build knowledge tracing models that are better equipped to support personalized learning and improve educational outcomes for students.
The KTbench framework also serves as a model for addressing data leakage issues in other areas of machine learning and artificial intelligence, where the trustworthiness and reliability of the underlying data are critical. As the field of AI continues to evolve, frameworks like KTbench will become increasingly important for ensuring the integrity and transparency of the research and its real-world applications.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
KTbench: A Novel Data Leakage-Free Framework for Knowledge Tracing
Yahya Badran, Christine Preisach
Knowledge Tracing (KT) is concerned with predicting students' future performance on learning items in intelligent tutoring systems. Learning items are tagged with skill labels called knowledge concepts (KCs). Many KT models expand the sequence of item-student interactions into KC-student interactions by replacing learning items with their constituting KCs. This often results in a longer sequence length. This approach addresses the issue of sparse item-student interactions and minimises model parameters. However, two problems have been identified with such models. The first problem is the model's ability to learn correlations between KCs belonging to the same item, which can result in the leakage of ground truth labels and hinder performance. This problem can lead to a significant decrease in performance on datasets with a higher number of KCs per item. The second problem is that the available benchmark implementations ignore accounting for changes in sequence length when expanding KCs, leading to different models being tested with varying sequence lengths but still compared against the same benchmark. To address these problems, we introduce a general masking framework that mitigates the first problem and enhances the performance of such KT models while preserving the original model architecture without significant alterations. Additionally, we introduce KTbench, an open-source benchmark library designed to ensure the reproducibility of this work while mitigating the second problem.
Read more4/12/2024
🧪
0
A Survey of Knowledge Tracing: Models, Variants, and Applications
Shuanghong Shen, Qi Liu, Zhenya Huang, Yonghe Zheng, Minghao Yin, Minjuan Wang, Enhong Chen
Modern online education has the capacity to provide intelligent educational services by automatically analyzing substantial amounts of student behavioral data. Knowledge Tracing (KT) is one of the fundamental tasks for student behavioral data analysis, aiming to monitor students' evolving knowledge state during their problem-solving process. In recent years, a substantial number of studies have concentrated on this rapidly growing field, significantly contributing to its advancements. In this survey, we will conduct a thorough investigation of these progressions. Firstly, we present three types of fundamental KT models with distinct technical routes. Subsequently, we review extensive variants of the fundamental KT models that consider more stringent learning assumptions. Moreover, the development of KT cannot be separated from its applications, thereby we present typical KT applications in various scenarios. To facilitate the work of researchers and practitioners in this field, we have developed two open-source algorithm libraries: EduData that enables the download and preprocessing of KT-related datasets, and EduKTM that provides an extensible and unified implementation of existing mainstream KT models. Finally, we discuss potential directions for future research in this rapidly growing field. We hope that the current survey will assist both researchers and practitioners in fostering the development of KT, thereby benefiting a broader range of students.
Read more4/12/2024
0
Personalized Knowledge Tracing through Student Representation Reconstruction and Class Imbalance Mitigation
Zhiyu Chen, Wei Ji, Jing Xiao, Zitao Liu
Knowledge tracing is a technique that predicts students' future performance by analyzing their learning process through historical interactions with intelligent educational platforms, enabling a precise evaluation of their knowledge mastery. Recent studies have achieved significant progress by leveraging powerful deep neural networks. These models construct complex input representations using questions, skills, and other auxiliary information but overlook individual student characteristics, which limits the capability for personalized assessment. Additionally, the available datasets in the field exhibit class imbalance issues. The models that simply predict all responses as correct without substantial effort can yield impressive accuracy. In this paper, we propose PKT, a novel approach for personalized knowledge tracing. PKT reconstructs representations from sequences of interactions with a tutoring platform to capture latent information about the students. Moreover, PKT incorporates focal loss to improve prioritize minority classes, thereby achieving more balanced predictions. Extensive experimental results on four publicly available educational datasets demonstrate the advanced predictive performance of PKT in comparison with 16 state-of-the-art models. To ensure the reproducibility of our research, the code is publicly available at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/PKT.
Read more9/12/2024
0
A Question-centric Multi-experts Contrastive Learning Framework for Improving the Accuracy and Interpretability of Deep Sequential Knowledge Tracing Models
Hengyuan Zhang, Zitao Liu, Chenming Shang, Dawei Li, Yong Jiang
Knowledge tracing (KT) plays a crucial role in predicting students' future performance by analyzing their historical learning processes. Deep neural networks (DNNs) have shown great potential in solving the KT problem. However, there still exist some important challenges when applying deep learning techniques to model the KT process. The first challenge lies in taking the individual information of the question into modeling. This is crucial because, despite questions sharing the same knowledge component (KC), students' knowledge acquisition on homogeneous questions can vary significantly. The second challenge lies in interpreting the prediction results from existing deep learning-based KT models. In real-world applications, while it may not be necessary to have complete transparency and interpretability of the model parameters, it is crucial to present the model's prediction results in a manner that teachers find interpretable. This makes teachers accept the rationale behind the prediction results and utilize them to design teaching activities and tailored learning strategies for students. However, the inherent black-box nature of deep learning techniques often poses a hurdle for teachers to fully embrace the model's prediction results. To address these challenges, we propose a Question-centric Multi-experts Contrastive Learning framework for KT called Q-MCKT. We have provided all the datasets and code on our website at https://github.com/rattlesnakey/Q-MCKT.
Read more7/8/2024