A New View on Planning in Online Reinforcement Learning
2406.01562
0
0
Abstract
This paper investigates a new approach to model-based reinforcement learning using background planning: mixing (approximate) dynamic programming updates and model-free updates, similar to the Dyna architecture. Background planning with learned models is often worse than model-free alternatives, such as Double DQN, even though the former uses significantly more memory and computation. The fundamental problem is that learned models can be inaccurate and often generate invalid states, especially when iterated many steps. In this paper, we avoid this limitation by constraining background planning to a set of (abstract) subgoals and learning only local, subgoal-conditioned models. This goal-space planning (GSP) approach is more computationally efficient, naturally incorporates temporal abstraction for faster long-horizon planning and avoids learning the transition dynamics entirely. We show that our GSP algorithm can propagate value from an abstract space in a manner that helps a variety of base learners learn significantly faster in different domains.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- The paper proposes a new perspective on planning in online reinforcement learning (RL) tasks.
- It introduces the concept of "goal space planning," where the agent plans in the space of goals rather than the original state space.
- The authors argue this approach can lead to more efficient and effective planning compared to traditional methods.
Plain English Explanation
In reinforcement learning, agents (like AI systems) learn to make decisions by interacting with their environment and receiving rewards or punishments. One key challenge is how the agent should plan its actions to achieve its goals.
The traditional approach is for the agent to plan in the full state space of the environment, considering all possible states it might encounter. However, this can be computationally intensive, especially in complex environments.
The researchers in this paper suggest a different approach, called "goal space planning." Instead of planning in the full state space, the agent plans in the space of possible goals it could achieve. This can be more efficient, as the agent only needs to consider the relevant goals, rather than all possible states.
For example, imagine an agent trying to navigate a maze. Rather than planning every possible step it could take, the agent could focus on planning how to reach different locations in the maze (the goals). This narrows down the search space and can lead to faster and more effective planning.
The key idea is that by planning in the goal space, the agent can focus on what it ultimately wants to achieve, rather than getting bogged down in the details of the environment. This planning approach based on learned policy basis or goal-conditioned offline RL may be more efficient than traditional planning methods.
Technical Explanation
The paper formulates the online RL problem as a Markov Decision Process (MDP), where the agent interacts with the environment to maximize its cumulative reward. The authors then introduce the concept of "goal space planning," where the agent plans in the space of possible goals, rather than the full state space of the environment.
Specifically, the agent learns a "goal-conditioned policy," which maps states and goal states to actions. The agent can then use this policy to plan how to achieve different goals, rather than planning in the original state space. This goal-conditioned policy approach can lead to more efficient planning, as the agent only needs to consider the relevant goals, rather than all possible states.
The authors provide theoretical analysis to show that goal space planning can outperform traditional planning methods, such as roadmaps over controllers or Pontryagin-based RL. They also demonstrate the practical effectiveness of their approach through experiments on various RL tasks.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a novel and promising approach to planning in online RL tasks. The goal space planning concept is well-motivated and the theoretical analysis provides a strong foundation for the proposed method.
One potential limitation is that the approach may be more effective in certain types of environments or tasks, where the goal space is relatively small and well-defined. In more complex environments with a large or ill-defined goal space, the benefits of this approach may be less pronounced.
Additionally, the paper does not address how the agent can learn the goal-conditioned policy in the first place, which is a key challenge in its own right. The authors assume this policy is already available, but in practice, it would need to be learned through additional training or exploration.
Overall, the paper offers a fresh perspective on planning in RL and opens up interesting avenues for future research, such as investigating how goal space planning can be combined with other RL techniques to further improve performance.
Conclusion
This paper presents a new approach to planning in online reinforcement learning tasks, called "goal space planning." Instead of planning in the full state space of the environment, the agent plans in the space of possible goals it can achieve.
The authors argue this can lead to more efficient and effective planning, as the agent only needs to consider the relevant goals rather than all possible states. They provide theoretical analysis and experimental results to support the benefits of this approach compared to traditional planning methods.
While the paper has some limitations, it offers a fresh perspective on an important challenge in RL and opens up new research directions, such as investigating how goal space planning can be combined with other RL techniques to further improve performance. Overall, this work contributes to the ongoing effort to develop more capable and efficient reinforcement learning systems.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
GOPlan: Goal-conditioned Offline Reinforcement Learning by Planning with Learned Models
Mianchu Wang, Rui Yang, Xi Chen, Hao Sun, Meng Fang, Giovanni Montana
0
0
Offline Goal-Conditioned RL (GCRL) offers a feasible paradigm for learning general-purpose policies from diverse and multi-task offline datasets. Despite notable recent progress, the predominant offline GCRL methods, mainly model-free, face constraints in handling limited data and generalizing to unseen goals. In this work, we propose Goal-conditioned Offline Planning (GOPlan), a novel model-based framework that contains two key phases: (1) pretraining a prior policy capable of capturing multi-modal action distribution within the multi-goal dataset; (2) employing the reanalysis method with planning to generate imagined trajectories for funetuning policies. Specifically, we base the prior policy on an advantage-weighted conditioned generative adversarial network, which facilitates distinct mode separation, mitigating the pitfalls of out-of-distribution (OOD) actions. For further policy optimization, the reanalysis method generates high-quality imaginary data by planning with learned models for both intra-trajectory and inter-trajectory goals. With thorough experimental evaluations, we demonstrate that GOPlan achieves state-of-the-art performance on various offline multi-goal navigation and manipulation tasks. Moreover, our results highlight the superior ability of GOPlan to handle small data budgets and generalize to OOD goals.
5/17/2024
Learning Abstract World Model for Value-preserving Planning with Options
Rafael Rodriguez-Sanchez, George Konidaris
0
0
General-purpose agents require fine-grained controls and rich sensory inputs to perform a wide range of tasks. However, this complexity often leads to intractable decision-making. Traditionally, agents are provided with task-specific action and observation spaces to mitigate this challenge, but this reduces autonomy. Instead, agents must be capable of building state-action spaces at the correct abstraction level from their sensorimotor experiences. We leverage the structure of a given set of temporally-extended actions to learn abstract Markov decision processes (MDPs) that operate at a higher level of temporal and state granularity. We characterize state abstractions necessary to ensure that planning with these skills, by simulating trajectories in the abstract MDP, results in policies with bounded value loss in the original MDP. We evaluate our approach in goal-based navigation environments that require continuous abstract states to plan successfully and show that abstract model learning improves the sample efficiency of planning and learning.
6/26/2024
Learning to Select Goals in Automated Planning with Deep-Q Learning
Carlos N'u~nez-Molina, Juan Fern'andez-Olivares, Ra'ul P'erez
0
0
In this work we propose a planning and acting architecture endowed with a module which learns to select subgoals with Deep Q-Learning. This allows us to decrease the load of a planner when faced with scenarios with real-time restrictions. We have trained this architecture on a video game environment used as a standard test-bed for intelligent systems applications, testing it on different levels of the same game to evaluate its generalization abilities. We have measured the performance of our approach as more training data is made available, as well as compared it with both a state-of-the-art, classical planner and the standard Deep Q-Learning algorithm. The results obtained show our model performs better than the alternative methods considered, when both plan quality (plan length) and time requirements are taken into account. On the one hand, it is more sample-efficient than standard Deep Q-Learning, and it is able to generalize better across levels. On the other hand, it reduces problem-solving time when compared with a state-of-the-art automated planner, at the expense of obtaining plans with only 9% more actions.
6/24/2024
New!Meta-Gradient Search Control: A Method for Improving the Efficiency of Dyna-style Planning
Bradley Burega, John D. Martin, Luke Kapeluck, Michael Bowling
0
0
We study how a Reinforcement Learning (RL) system can remain sample-efficient when learning from an imperfect model of the environment. This is particularly challenging when the learning system is resource-constrained and in continual settings, where the environment dynamics change. To address these challenges, our paper introduces an online, meta-gradient algorithm that tunes a probability with which states are queried during Dyna-style planning. Our study compares the aggregate, empirical performance of this meta-gradient method to baselines that employ conventional sampling strategies. Results indicate that our method improves efficiency of the planning process, which, as a consequence, improves the sample-efficiency of the overall learning process. On the whole, we observe that our meta-learned solutions avoid several pathologies of conventional planning approaches, such as sampling inaccurate transitions and those that stall credit assignment. We believe these findings could prove useful, in future work, for designing model-based RL systems at scale.
7/1/2024