Object-Centric Conformance Alignments with Synchronization (Extended Version)
0
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents a new approach for aligning object-centric event logs with object-centric Petri nets, called object-centric conformance alignments with synchronization.
- The method allows for conformance checking of object-centric processes, where the behavior of individual objects is considered rather than just the overall process.
- The authors develop a formal definition of object-centric event logs and object-centric Petri nets, and propose an algorithm to compute optimal alignments between the two.
Plain English Explanation
In many business processes, the behavior of individual "objects" (e.g., customers, orders, or products) is just as important as the overall process flow. [object Object] refers to this as an "object-centric" view.
The authors of this paper wanted to develop a way to check how well a real-world process (captured in an "event log") matches an idealized process model (represented as an "object-centric Petri net"). This is called "conformance checking." However, traditional conformance checking techniques are not well-suited for object-centric processes.
The key innovation of this work is an algorithm that can align the behavior of individual objects in the event log with the corresponding objects in the Petri net model. This allows the researchers to identify discrepancies between the real-world process and the model, and understand where improvements could be made. [object Object] discusses a related problem in the multi-agent setting.
The authors provide a formal mathematical framework for defining object-centric event logs and Petri nets, and then describe their alignment algorithm in detail. This technical approach enables robust conformance checking for object-centric business processes, which is an important practical problem.
Technical Explanation
The paper first defines the concept of an "object-centric event log," which captures the behavior of individual objects (e.g., customers, orders) rather than just the overall process flow. This is in contrast to traditional "case-based" event logs.
The authors then introduce the idea of an "object-centric Petri net," which is an extension of standard Petri nets that can model the lifecycle of individual objects. These Petri nets have special "identifier" places that track the state of each object.
The core technical contribution is an algorithm that can align the behavior observed in an object-centric event log with the behavior specified by an object-centric Petri net. This "object-centric conformance alignment" identifies discrepancies between the real-world process and the model, allowing for better process analysis and improvement.
[object Object] discusses a related problem of aligning model outputs with desired behavior.
The authors prove that their alignment algorithm is optimal, in the sense that it minimizes the "cost" of the alignment. They also demonstrate the practical applicability of their approach through experiments on real-world object-centric event logs.
Critical Analysis
The paper makes a convincing case for the importance of object-centric conformance checking, and the authors have developed a robust technical solution. However, there are a few potential limitations and areas for future research:
-
The alignment algorithm assumes that the object-centric Petri net accurately captures the intended process behavior. In practice, the Petri net model may be incomplete or incorrect, which could limit the usefulness of the alignments.
-
The authors focus on aligning the control-flow perspective (i.e., the sequence of activities) but do not address other perspectives, such as data or resources. [object Object] discusses a more holistic approach to objective alignment.
-
The computational complexity of the alignment algorithm may be a concern for large-scale event logs and process models. Techniques for improving scalability could be an area for future research.
Overall, this paper makes an important contribution to the field of object-centric process mining and conformance checking. The technical approach is solid, and the potential practical applications are significant. Further research to address the limitations mentioned could help strengthen the framework even further.
Conclusion
This paper presents a novel approach for aligning object-centric event logs with object-centric Petri net models, enabling robust conformance checking for business processes where the behavior of individual objects is paramount. The authors' technical solution is a significant advancement in the field of object-centric process mining, with potential applications in a wide range of industries and use cases.
[object Object] discusses a related problem of aligning multiple sources of knowledge, which could be a useful analogy for understanding the challenges addressed in this paper.
Overall, this research contributes important theoretical and practical insights that could help organizations better understand and improve their object-centric business processes.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
0
Object-Centric Conformance Alignments with Synchronization (Extended Version)
Alessandro Gianola, Marco Montali, Sarah Winkler
Real-world processes operate on objects that are inter-dependent. To accurately reflect the nature of such processes, object-centric process mining techniques are needed, notably conformance checking. However, while the object-centric perspective has recently gained traction, few concrete process mining techniques have been presented so far. Moreover, existing approaches are severely limited in their abilities to keep track of object identity and object dependencies. Consequently, serious problems in logs remain undetected. In this paper, we present a new formalism that combines the key modelling features of two existing approaches, in particular the ability of object-centric Petri nets to capture one-to-many relations and the one of Petri nets with identifiers to compare and synchronize objects based on their identity. We call the resulting formalism 'object-centric Petri nets with identifiers', and define alignments and the conformance checking task for this setting. We propose a conformance checking approach for such nets based on an encoding in satisfiability modulo theories (SMT), and illustrate how it can be effectively used to overcome shortcomings of earlier work. To assess its practicality, we perform an evaluation on data from the literature.
Read more4/8/2024
0
A Scalable and Near-Optimal Conformance Checking Approach for Long Traces
Eli Bogdanov, Izack Cohen, Avigdor Gal
Long traces and large event logs that originate from sensors and prediction models are becoming more common in our data-rich world. In such circumstances, conformance checking, a key task in process mining, can become computationally infeasible due to the exponential complexity of finding an optimal alignment. This paper introduces a novel sliding window approach to address these scalability challenges while preserving the interpretability of alignment-based methods. By breaking down traces into manageable subtraces and iteratively aligning each with the process model, our method significantly reduces the search space. The approach uses global information that captures structural properties of the trace and the process model to make informed alignment decisions, discarding unpromising alignments even if they are optimal for a local subtrace. This improves the overall accuracy of the results. Experimental evaluations demonstrate that the proposed method consistently finds optimal alignments in most cases and highlight its scalability. This is further supported by a theoretical complexity analysis, which shows the reduced growth of the search space compared to other common conformance checking methods. This work provides a valuable contribution towards efficient conformance checking for large-scale process mining applications.
Read more6/11/2024
🔄
0
Reachset-Conformant System Identification
Laura Lutzow, Matthias Althoff
Formal verification techniques play a pivotal role in ensuring the safety of complex cyber-physical systems. To transfer model-based verification results to the real world, we require that the measurements of the target system lie in the set of reachable outputs of the corresponding model, a property we refer to as reachset conformance. This paper is on automatically identifying those reachset-conformant models. While state-of-the-art reachset-conformant identification methods focus on linear state-space models, we generalize these methods to nonlinear state-space models and linear and nonlinear input-output models. Furthermore, our identification framework adapts to different levels of prior knowledge on the system dynamics. In particular, we identify the set of model uncertainties for white-box models, the parameters and the set of model uncertainties for gray-box models, and entire reachset-conformant black-box models from data. For the black-box identification, we propose a new genetic programming variant, which we call conformant genetic programming. The robustness and efficacy of our framework are demonstrated in extensive numerical experiments using simulated and real-world data.
Read more7/17/2024
0
Conformance Checking of Fuzzy Logs against Declarative Temporal Specifications
Ivan Donadello, Paolo Felli, Craig Innes, Fabrizio Maria Maggi, Marco Montali
Traditional conformance checking tasks assume that event data provide a faithful and complete representation of the actual process executions. This assumption has been recently questioned: more and more often events are not traced explicitly, but are instead indirectly obtained as the result of event recognition pipelines, and thus inherently come with uncertainty. In this work, differently from the typical probabilistic interpretation of uncertainty, we consider the relevant case where uncertainty refers to which activity is actually conducted, under a fuzzy semantics. In this novel setting, we consider the problem of checking whether fuzzy event data conform with declarative temporal rules specified as Declare patterns or, more generally, as formulae of linear temporal logic over finite traces (LTLf). This requires to relax the assumption that at each instant only one activity is executed, and to correspondingly redefine boolean operators of the logic with a fuzzy semantics. Specifically, we provide a threefold contribution. First, we define a fuzzy counterpart of LTLf tailored to our purpose. Second, we cast conformance checking over fuzzy logs as a verification problem in this logic. Third, we provide a proof-of-concept, efficient implementation based on the PyTorch Python library, suited to check conformance of multiple fuzzy traces at once.
Read more6/19/2024