PrefCLM: Enhancing Preference-based Reinforcement Learning with Crowdsourced Large Language Models
0
🏅
Sign in to get full access
Overview
- This paper introduces a novel framework called PrefCLM that uses crowdsourced large language models (LLMs) as simulated teachers in preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL).
- PbRL is an approach to teaching robots through human comparative feedback, rather than complex reward engineering.
- Existing PbRL methods often rely on synthetic feedback from scripted teachers, which can struggle to adapt to the nuanced preferences of human-robot interaction (HRI) scenarios.
- PrefCLM aims to address these challenges by fusing individual preferences from multiple LLM agents and facilitating collective refinements based on user interactive feedback.
Plain English Explanation
Preference-based Reinforcement Learning (PbRL) is a way of teaching robots new skills by having humans provide feedback on the robot's actions, rather than trying to define a complex reward system. This approach can be more natural and efficient than traditional reinforcement learning.
However, existing PbRL methods often rely on scripted teachers to provide the feedback, which can struggle to capture the unique preferences and expectations that humans might have in real-world human-robot interaction (HRI) scenarios.
To address this, the researchers introduce PrefCLM, a new framework that uses crowdsourced large language models (LLMs) as simulated teachers in PbRL. The key idea is to leverage the collective intelligence of multiple LLM agents, each with their own unique preferences, and use Dempster-Shafer Theory to fuse their feedback in a way that is efficient and adaptable to individual user preferences.
The framework also includes a human-in-the-loop pipeline that allows users to provide interactive feedback to refine the robot's behavior, further tailoring it to their specific needs and expectations.
By using this approach, the researchers aim to create robot behaviors that are more natural and aligned with individual user preferences, ultimately enhancing user satisfaction in HRI scenarios.
Technical Explanation
The paper introduces the PrefCLM framework, which leverages crowdsourced large language models (LLMs) as simulated teachers in preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL).
The key components of the PrefCLM framework are:
- LLM-based Preference Modeling: Multiple LLM agents are used to generate preference scores for different action trajectories, capturing a diverse range of perspectives and preferences.
- Dempster-Shafer Fusion: The Dempster-Shafer Theory is used to combine the individual preference scores from the LLM agents, efficiently leveraging their collective intelligence.
- Human-in-the-Loop Refinement: A human-in-the-loop pipeline is introduced, allowing users to provide interactive feedback to refine the robot's behavior and tailor it to their individual preferences.
The researchers evaluate PrefCLM across various general reinforcement learning tasks and compare its performance to traditional scripted teachers. The results show that PrefCLM achieves competitive performance and is able to facilitate more natural and efficient robot behaviors.
Furthermore, a real-world user study with 10 participants demonstrates PrefCLM's ability to tailor robot behaviors to individual user preferences, significantly enhancing user satisfaction in HRI scenarios.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to addressing the challenges of existing PbRL methods, which often struggle to adapt to the nuanced preferences of human-robot interaction scenarios.
One potential limitation of the PrefCLM framework is its reliance on the availability and quality of the crowdsourced LLM agents. If the LLM models do not adequately capture the diversity of human preferences, or if they exhibit biases or inconsistencies, this could impact the effectiveness of the Dempster-Shafer fusion process.
Additionally, the human-in-the-loop refinement process, while a valuable feature, may place a significant burden on users in terms of the time and effort required to provide interactive feedback. Exploring ways to streamline this process or reduce the required user input could further enhance the usability and scalability of the framework.
The authors acknowledge that the real-world user study, while demonstrating the potential of PrefCLM, was relatively small in scale. Expanding the study to a larger and more diverse user population would provide valuable insights into the framework's broader applicability and generalizability.
Overall, the PrefCLM framework presents an intriguing approach to leveraging crowdsourced LLMs and collective intelligence for preference-based reinforcement learning. Further research and refinement could lead to significant advancements in the field of human-robot interaction and the development of more personalized and satisfying robotic systems.
Conclusion
The PrefCLM framework introduced in this paper represents a novel approach to preference-based reinforcement learning, addressing the limitations of existing methods that rely on scripted teachers and struggle to adapt to the nuanced preferences of human-robot interaction scenarios.
By utilizing crowdsourced large language models as simulated teachers and employing Dempster-Shafer Theory to fuse their diverse preferences, PrefCLM aims to create robot behaviors that are more natural and aligned with individual user expectations. The inclusion of a human-in-the-loop refinement process further enhances the framework's ability to tailor robotic systems to the specific needs and preferences of users.
The results presented in the paper indicate that PrefCLM can achieve competitive performance compared to traditional approaches, while also facilitating more efficient and satisfying human-robot interactions. As the field of robotics continues to advance, the insights and techniques introduced in this work could have significant implications for the development of personalized, user-centric robotic systems that seamlessly integrate into our daily lives.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏅
0
PrefCLM: Enhancing Preference-based Reinforcement Learning with Crowdsourced Large Language Models
Ruiqi Wang, Dezhong Zhao, Ziqin Yuan, Ike Obi, Byung-Cheol Min
Preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL) is emerging as a promising approach to teaching robots through human comparative feedback, sidestepping the need for complex reward engineering. However, the substantial volume of feedback required in existing PbRL methods often lead to reliance on synthetic feedback generated by scripted teachers. This approach necessitates intricate reward engineering again and struggles to adapt to the nuanced preferences particular to human-robot interaction (HRI) scenarios, where users may have unique expectations toward the same task. To address these challenges, we introduce PrefCLM, a novel framework that utilizes crowdsourced large language models (LLMs) as simulated teachers in PbRL. We utilize Dempster-Shafer Theory to fuse individual preferences from multiple LLM agents at the score level, efficiently leveraging their diversity and collective intelligence. We also introduce a human-in-the-loop pipeline that facilitates collective refinements based on user interactive feedback. Experimental results across various general RL tasks show that PrefCLM achieves competitive performance compared to traditional scripted teachers and excels in facilitating more more natural and efficient behaviors. A real-world user study (N=10) further demonstrates its capability to tailor robot behaviors to individual user preferences, significantly enhancing user satisfaction in HRI scenarios.
Read more7/12/2024
0
Beyond Human Preferences: Exploring Reinforcement Learning Trajectory Evaluation and Improvement through LLMs
Zichao Shen, Tianchen Zhu, Qingyun Sun, Shiqi Gao, Jianxin Li
Reinforcement learning (RL) faces challenges in evaluating policy trajectories within intricate game tasks due to the difficulty in designing comprehensive and precise reward functions. This inherent difficulty curtails the broader application of RL within game environments characterized by diverse constraints. Preference-based reinforcement learning (PbRL) presents a pioneering framework that capitalizes on human preferences as pivotal reward signals, thereby circumventing the need for meticulous reward engineering. However, obtaining preference data from human experts is costly and inefficient, especially under conditions marked by complex constraints. To tackle this challenge, we propose a LLM-enabled automatic preference generation framework named LLM4PG , which harnesses the capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to abstract trajectories, rank preferences, and reconstruct reward functions to optimize conditioned policies. Experiments on tasks with complex language constraints demonstrated the effectiveness of our LLM-enabled reward functions, accelerating RL convergence and overcoming stagnation caused by slow or absent progress under original reward structures. This approach mitigates the reliance on specialized human knowledge and demonstrates the potential of LLMs to enhance RL's effectiveness in complex environments in the wild.
Read more7/2/2024
0
Orchestrating LLMs with Different Personalizations
Jin Peng Zhou, Katie Z Luo, Jingwen Gu, Jason Yuan, Kilian Q. Weinberger, Wen Sun
This paper presents a novel approach to aligning large language models (LLMs) with individual human preferences, sometimes referred to as Reinforcement Learning from textit{Personalized} Human Feedback (RLPHF). Given stated preferences along multiple dimensions, such as helpfulness, conciseness, or humor, the goal is to create an LLM without re-training that best adheres to this specification. Starting from specialized expert LLMs, each trained for one such particular preference dimension, we propose a black-box method that merges their outputs on a per-token level. We train a lightweight Preference Control Model (PCM) that dynamically translates the preference description and current context into next-token prediction weights. By combining the expert models' outputs at the token level, our approach dynamically generates text that optimizes the given preference. Empirical tests show that our method matches or surpasses existing preference merging techniques, providing a scalable, efficient alternative to fine-tuning LLMs for individual personalization.
Read more7/8/2024
0
Personalized Language Modeling from Personalized Human Feedback
Xinyu Li, Zachary C. Lipton, Liu Leqi
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) is commonly used to fine-tune large language models to better align with human preferences. However, the underlying premise of algorithms developed under this framework can be problematic when user preferences encoded in human feedback are diverse. In this work, we aim to address this problem by developing methods for building personalized language models. We first formally introduce the task of learning from personalized human feedback and explain why vanilla RLHF can be ineffective in this context. We then propose a general Personalized-RLHF (P-RLHF) framework, including a user model that maps user information to user representations and can flexibly encode our assumptions on user preferences. We develop new learning objectives to perform personalized Direct Preference Optimization that jointly learns a user model and a personalized language model. We demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed method through (1) a synthetic task where we fine-tune a GPT-J 6B model to align with users with conflicting preferences on generation length; and (2) an instruction following task where we fine-tune a Tulu-7B model to generate responses for users with diverse preferences on the style of responses. In both cases, our learned models can generate personalized responses that are better aligned with the preferences of individual users.
Read more7/9/2024