PromptReps: Prompting Large Language Models to Generate Dense and Sparse Representations for Zero-Shot Document Retrieval

Overview

• Current methods for using large language models (LLMs) for zero-shot document ranking fall into two categories: prompt-based re-ranking and unsupervised contrastive trained dense retrieval.
• Prompt-based re-ranking is feasible for only a small number of documents due to high computational costs.
• Unsupervised contrastive trained dense retrieval can retrieve from the entire corpus, but requires a large amount of paired text data for training.

Plain English Explanation

The paper introduces a new method called PromptReps that aims to combine the advantages of these two approaches. PromptReps uses prompts to guide an LLM to generate representations of queries and documents for effective document retrieval, without the need for further training.

The key idea is to prompt the LLM to represent a given text using a single word. The model's last token's hidden states and the corresponding logits associated with predicting the next token are then used to construct a hybrid document retrieval system. This system leverages both dense text embeddings and sparse bag-of-words representations from the LLM.

The paper's experiments on zero-shot document retrieval datasets show that this simple prompt-based approach can achieve similar or better retrieval effectiveness compared to state-of-the-art LLM embedding methods that require large amounts of unsupervised training data, especially when using a larger LLM.

Technical Explanation

The paper proposes PromptReps, a new method for using large language models (LLMs) for zero-shot document ranking. PromptReps combines the advantages of two existing approaches:

1. Prompt-based re-ranking methods, which require no further training but are limited to re-ranking a small number of candidate documents due to high computational costs.
2. Unsupervised contrastive trained dense retrieval methods, which can retrieve relevant documents from the entire corpus but require a large amount of paired text data for training.

PromptReps uses prompts to guide an LLM to generate query and document representations for effective document retrieval, without the need for training. Specifically, the LLM is prompted to represent a given text using a single word. The last token's hidden states and the corresponding logits associated with predicting the next token are then used to construct a hybrid document retrieval system that leverages both dense text embeddings and sparse bag-of-words representations from the LLM.

The paper's experimental evaluation on BEIR zero-shot document retrieval datasets shows that this simple prompt-based LLM retrieval method can achieve similar or higher retrieval effectiveness than state-of-the-art LLM embedding methods that require large amounts of unsupervised training data, especially when using a larger LLM.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a novel and promising approach to leveraging LLMs for zero-shot document retrieval. By combining the strengths of prompt-based and unsupervised contrastive trained methods, PromptReps offers a computationally efficient way to retrieve relevant documents from the entire corpus without the need for extensive training.

However, the paper also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. For example, the performance of PromptReps may be sensitive to the choice of prompts, and the method may not be as effective for narrow or specialized domains where more targeted training data is required.

Additionally, the paper does not address potential biases or fairness issues that may arise from the use of LLMs, which are known to exhibit biases and limitations. Further research is needed to understand the broader implications and potential drawbacks of using PromptReps in real-world applications.

Overall, the paper presents an interesting and valuable contribution to the field of document retrieval using LLMs. However, it is important for researchers and practitioners to carefully consider the limitations and potential risks of such methods, and to continue exploring ways to improve their robustness and fairness.

Conclusion

The paper introduces PromptReps, a novel method for using large language models (LLMs) for zero-shot document ranking. PromptReps combines the advantages of prompt-based re-ranking and unsupervised contrastive trained dense retrieval, allowing for effective document retrieval from the entire corpus without the need for further training.

The experimental results show that PromptReps can achieve similar or better retrieval effectiveness compared to state-of-the-art LLM embedding methods, particularly when using a larger LLM. This suggests that prompt-based approaches can be a promising alternative to more resource-intensive training methods for LLM-based document retrieval systems.

While the paper presents a valuable contribution, it also highlights the need for further research to address the limitations and potential risks of using LLMs for such applications. Ongoing work in this area will be crucial to ensure the development of robust and fair document retrieval systems that can be deployed in real-world settings.