PromptWizard: Task-Aware Agent-driven Prompt Optimization Framework
2405.18369
0
0
🛠️
Abstract
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized AI across diverse domains, showcasing remarkable capabilities. Central to their success is the concept of prompting, which guides model output generation. However, manual prompt engineering is labor-intensive and domain-specific, necessitating automated solutions. This paper introduces PromptWizard, a novel framework leveraging LLMs to iteratively synthesize and refine prompts tailored to specific tasks. Unlike existing approaches, PromptWizard optimizes both prompt instructions and in-context examples, maximizing model performance. The framework iteratively refines prompts by mutating instructions and incorporating negative examples to deepen understanding and ensure diversity. It further enhances both instructions and examples with the aid of a critic, synthesizing new instructions and examples enriched with detailed reasoning steps for optimal performance. PromptWizard offers several key features and capabilities, including computational efficiency compared to state-of-the-art approaches, adaptability to scenarios with varying amounts of training data, and effectiveness with smaller LLMs. Rigorous evaluation across 35 tasks on 8 datasets demonstrates PromptWizard's superiority over existing prompt strategies, showcasing its efficacy and scalability in prompt optimization.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized AI across diverse domains, showcasing remarkable capabilities
- Prompting is central to their success, guiding model output generation
- Manual prompt engineering is labor-intensive and domain-specific, necessitating automated solutions
- This paper introduces PromptWizard, a novel framework leveraging LLMs to iteratively synthesize and refine prompts tailored to specific tasks
Plain English Explanation
Large language models (LLMs) are a type of AI system that have become incredibly powerful at tasks like natural language processing, question answering, and text generation. A key part of how these models work is the concept of "prompting" - providing the model with specific instructions or examples that guide its output.
However, manually crafting effective prompts is a tedious and time-consuming process that requires deep domain expertise. PromptWizard aims to automate this process by using LLMs to iteratively generate and refine prompts for specific tasks. Unlike existing approaches, PromptWizard optimizes both the prompt instructions and the in-context examples, which helps maximize the model's performance.
The framework works by repeatedly modifying the prompt instructions and incorporating negative examples to help the model develop a deeper understanding of the task. It also uses a "critic" component to further enhance both the instructions and examples, adding detailed reasoning steps to produce optimal prompts. This leads to prompts that are more computationally efficient, adaptable to different data scenarios, and effective even with smaller LLMs.
Technical Explanation
PromptWizard is a novel framework that leverages large language models (LLMs) to automatically synthesize and refine prompts for specific tasks. Unlike existing prompt tuning or prompt selection approaches, PromptWizard optimizes both the prompt instructions and the in-context examples used to guide the model's output.
The framework works in an iterative fashion, mutating the prompt instructions and incorporating negative examples to deepen the model's understanding of the task. It also employs a "critic" component that helps enhance both the instructions and examples, adding detailed reasoning steps to produce prompts that achieve optimal performance.
PromptWizard offers several key advantages over state-of-the-art methods, including:
- Improved computational efficiency
- Adaptability to scenarios with varying amounts of training data
- Effectiveness even when using smaller LLMs
The paper presents a rigorous evaluation of PromptWizard across 35 tasks on 8 datasets, demonstrating its superiority over existing prompt strategies and showcasing its scalability in prompt optimization.
Critical Analysis
The researchers thoroughly evaluate PromptWizard across a diverse range of tasks and datasets, providing compelling evidence for its effectiveness in automating prompt engineering. However, the paper does not address potential limitations or caveats of the approach.
For example, it would be valuable to understand how PromptWizard performs on tasks that require more complex reasoning or multi-step problem-solving, as the paper focuses primarily on relatively simple natural language processing tasks. Additionally, the researchers do not explore the potential biases or unintended behaviors that could emerge from the automated prompt generation process, which is an important consideration for real-world applications.
Further research could also investigate the interpretability and transparency of the PromptWizard framework, as well as its ability to generalize to unseen tasks or domains. AdvPrompter and Automatic Prompt Selection are related approaches that could provide useful insights for extending and improving the PromptWizard methodology.
Conclusion
This paper introduces PromptWizard, a novel framework that leverages large language models to automate the process of prompt engineering. By optimizing both the prompt instructions and in-context examples, PromptWizard is able to generate prompts that significantly outperform existing strategies across a wide range of tasks.
The key innovation of PromptWizard is its iterative approach to prompt refinement, which involves mutating instructions, incorporating negative examples, and using a critic to enhance the prompts. This leads to improved computational efficiency, adaptability to different data scenarios, and effectiveness even with smaller language models.
While the paper presents compelling evidence for the effectiveness of PromptWizard, further research is needed to explore its potential limitations, biases, and ability to generalize to more complex tasks. Nonetheless, this work represents an important step forward in automating the prompt engineering process, which could have significant implications for the broader field of large language model development and application.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
RePrompt: Planning by Automatic Prompt Engineering for Large Language Models Agents
Weizhe Chen, Sven Koenig, Bistra Dilkina
0
0
In this past year, large language models (LLMs) have had remarkable success in domains outside the traditional natural language processing, and people are starting to explore the usage of LLMs in more general and close to application domains like code generation, travel planning, and robot controls. Connecting these LLMs with great capacity and external tools, people are building the so-called LLM agents, which are supposed to help people do all kinds of work in everyday life. In all these domains, the prompt to the LLMs has been shown to make a big difference in what the LLM would generate and thus affect the performance of the LLM agents. Therefore, automatic prompt engineering has become an important question for many researchers and users of LLMs. In this paper, we propose a novel method, textsc{RePrompt}, which does gradient descent to optimize the step-by-step instructions in the prompt of the LLM agents based on the chat history obtained from interactions with LLM agents. By optimizing the prompt, the LLM will learn how to plan in specific domains. We have used experiments in PDDL generation and travel planning to show that our method could generally improve the performance for different reasoning tasks when using the updated prompt as the initial prompt.
6/18/2024
Towards Hierarchical Multi-Agent Workflows for Zero-Shot Prompt Optimization
Yuchi Liu, Jaskirat Singh, Gaowen Liu, Ali Payani, Liang Zheng
0
0
Large language models (LLMs) have shown great progress in responding to user questions, allowing for a multitude of diverse applications. Yet, the quality of LLM outputs heavily depends on the prompt design, where a good prompt might enable the LLM to answer a very challenging question correctly. Therefore, recent works have developed many strategies for improving the prompt, including both manual crafting and in-domain optimization. However, their efficacy in unrestricted scenarios remains questionable, as the former depends on human design for specific questions and the latter usually generalizes poorly to unseen scenarios. To address these problems, we give LLMs the freedom to design the best prompts according to themselves. Specifically, we include a hierarchy of LLMs, first constructing a prompt with precise instructions and accurate wording in a hierarchical manner, and then using this prompt to generate the final answer to the user query. We term this pipeline Hierarchical Multi-Agent Workflow, or HMAW. In contrast with prior works, HMAW imposes no human restriction and requires no training, and is completely task-agnostic while capable of adjusting to the nuances of the underlying task. Through both quantitative and qualitative experiments across multiple benchmarks, we verify that despite its simplicity, the proposed approach can create detailed and suitable prompts, further boosting the performance of current LLMs.
5/31/2024
🏅
PRewrite: Prompt Rewriting with Reinforcement Learning
Weize Kong, Spurthi Amba Hombaiah, Mingyang Zhang, Qiaozhu Mei, Michael Bendersky
0
0
Prompt engineering is critical for the development of LLM-based applications. However, it is usually done manually in a trial and error fashion that can be time consuming, ineffective, and sub-optimal. Even for the prompts which seemingly work well, there is always a lingering question: can the prompts be made better with further modifications? To address these problems, we investigate automated prompt engineering in this paper. Specifically, we propose PRewrite, an automated method to rewrite an under-optimized prompt to a more effective prompt. We instantiate the prompt rewriter using a LLM. The rewriter LLM is trained using reinforcement learning to optimize the performance on a given downstream task. We conduct experiments on diverse benchmark datasets, which demonstrates the effectiveness of PRewrite.
6/11/2024
Task Facet Learning: A Structured Approach to Prompt Optimization
Gurusha Juneja, Nagarajan Natarajan, Hua Li, Jian Jiao, Amit Sharma
0
0
Given a task in the form of a basic description and its training examples, prompt optimization is the problem of synthesizing the given information into a text prompt for a large language model (LLM). Humans solve this problem by also considering the different facets that define a task (e.g., counter-examples, explanations, analogies) and including them in the prompt. However, it is unclear whether existing algorithmic approaches, based on iteratively editing a given prompt or automatically selecting a few in-context examples, can cover the multiple facets required to solve a complex task. In this work, we view prompt optimization as that of learning multiple facets of a task from a set of training examples. We identify and exploit structure in the prompt optimization problem -- first, we find that prompts can be broken down into loosely coupled semantic sections that have a relatively independent effect on the prompt's performance; second, we cluster the input space and use clustered batches so that the optimization procedure can learn the different facets of a task across batches. The resulting algorithm, UniPrompt, consists of a generative model to generate initial candidates for each prompt section; and a feedback mechanism that aggregates suggested edits from multiple mini-batches into a conceptual description for the section. Empirical evaluation on multiple datasets and a real-world task shows that prompts generated using UniPrompt obtain higher accuracy than human-tuned prompts and those from state-of-the-art methods. In particular, our algorithm can generate long, complex prompts that existing methods are unable to generate. Code for UniPrompt will be available at url{https://aka.ms/uniprompt}.
6/18/2024