Struct-X: Enhancing Large Language Models Reasoning with Structured Data

Read original: arXiv:2407.12522 - Published 7/18/2024 by Xiaoyu Tan, Haoyu Wang, Xihe Qiu, Yuan Cheng, Yinghui Xu, Wei Chu, Yuan Qi

Struct-X: Enhancing Large Language Models Reasoning with Structured Data

Overview

This paper introduces Struct-X, a framework for enhancing large language models (LLMs) with the ability to reason about structured data.
Struct-X aims to bridge the gap between LLMs and structured knowledge, allowing models to better utilize and reason over information stored in tabular, graph, or other structured formats.
The paper presents several key components of the Struct-X framework, including a structured data encoding module, a structured reasoning module, and a structured output generation module.
Experiments on various benchmarks demonstrate that Struct-X can significantly improve LLM performance on tasks requiring structured reasoning, such as StructLM, StructBERT, and StructBench.

Plain English Explanation

Large language models (LLMs) are powerful AI systems that can understand and generate human-like text. However, they often struggle with tasks that require reasoning about structured data, such as tables, graphs, or databases. This is because LLMs are primarily trained on unstructured text, and they may not have a good understanding of how to effectively utilize and reason over structured information.

The Struct-X framework aims to address this limitation by enhancing LLMs with the ability to work with structured data. Struct-X includes several key components:

A structured data encoding module that can represent tabular, graph, or other structured data in a format that the LLM can understand.
A structured reasoning module that allows the LLM to perform logical operations and inferences over the structured data.
A structured output generation module that enables the LLM to generate responses that incorporate and build upon the structured information.

By incorporating these components, Struct-X can help LLMs become better at tasks that require structured reasoning, such as answering questions based on a database, summarizing key insights from a spreadsheet, or generating text that references specific facts or relationships in a knowledge graph.

The paper presents experiments that demonstrate the effectiveness of Struct-X on various benchmarks, including StructLM, StructBERT, and StructBench. These results suggest that Struct-X can significantly improve the ability of LLMs to reason about and utilize structured data, which could have important implications for a wide range of real-world applications.

Technical Explanation

The Struct-X framework consists of three key components:

Structured Data Encoding Module: This module takes structured data (e.g., tables, graphs) as input and encodes it in a format that can be effectively processed by the LLM. This may involve techniques such as graph neural networks or specialized tokenization schemes.
Structured Reasoning Module: This module integrates the encoded structured data with the LLM's language understanding capabilities, allowing the model to perform logical operations and inferences over the structured information. This may involve attention mechanisms, reasoning modules, or other specialized architectural components.
Structured Output Generation Module: This module enables the LLM to generate responses that incorporate and build upon the structured information, producing outputs that are coherent and relevant to the given task and data.

The paper presents experiments on several benchmarks to evaluate the performance of Struct-X:

StructLM: A benchmark that assesses an LLM's ability to reason about structured knowledge and generate relevant text.
StructBERT: A multilingual benchmark that tests an LLM's structured reasoning capabilities across different languages.
StructBench: A comprehensive benchmark suite that evaluates an LLM's performance on a wide range of tasks requiring structured reasoning.

The results demonstrate that Struct-X can significantly improve the performance of LLMs on these benchmarks, suggesting that the proposed framework is effective in bridging the gap between LLMs and structured data.

Critical Analysis

The Struct-X framework presents a promising approach to enhancing the structured reasoning capabilities of LLMs. However, the paper does acknowledge several potential limitations and areas for further research:

Scalability: The authors note that the current Struct-X implementation may not scale well to extremely large or complex structured data, and further work is needed to improve its efficiency and generalization.
Interpretability: While Struct-X improves the structured reasoning capabilities of LLMs, the inner workings of the model may still be opaque, making it challenging to understand how the model is making decisions and inferences.
Generalization: The paper focuses on specific benchmark tasks, and it remains to be seen how well Struct-X can generalize to a wider range of real-world applications that involve structured data.
Multimodal Integration: The current framework only considers structured data in isolation, and integrating it with other modalities, such as images or video, could further enhance the model's reasoning abilities.

Additionally, it would be valuable to see further research on the StructEXT benchmark, which specifically evaluates the structured reasoning capabilities of LLMs, and the Large Language Model Driven Meta-Structure Discovery approach, which aims to discover structured knowledge from LLM outputs.

Conclusion

The Struct-X framework represents a significant step forward in enhancing the structured reasoning capabilities of large language models. By incorporating specialized modules for encoding, reasoning, and generating structured data, Struct-X can help LLMs become better at tasks that require logical inference and manipulation of tabular, graph, or other forms of structured information.

The experiments presented in the paper demonstrate the effectiveness of Struct-X on various benchmarks, suggesting that this approach could have important implications for a wide range of real-world applications, from question-answering and data analysis to knowledge discovery and generation.

As the field of AI continues to evolve, the ability to seamlessly integrate structured data with language understanding will be crucial for developing more powerful and versatile AI systems. The Struct-X framework provides a promising direction for addressing this challenge and paves the way for future research in this area.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Struct-X: Enhancing Large Language Models Reasoning with Structured Data

Xiaoyu Tan, Haoyu Wang, Xihe Qiu, Yuan Cheng, Yinghui Xu, Wei Chu, Yuan Qi

Structured data, rich in logical and relational information, has the potential to enhance the reasoning abilities of large language models (LLMs). Still, its integration poses a challenge due to the risk of overwhelming LLMs with excessive tokens and irrelevant context information. To address this, we propose Struct-X, a novel framework that operates through five key phases: ``read-model-fill-reflect-reason'' efficiently enabling LLMs to utilize structured data. It begins by encoding structured data into a topological space using graph embeddings, followed by filling in missing entity information with knowledge retrieval modules, and filtering out irrelevant tokens via a self-supervised module. The final phase involves constructing a topological network with selected tokens to further reduce the total token length for more effective LLM inference. Additionally, Struct-X includes an Auxiliary Module trained to generate prompts, aiding LLMs in analyzing structured data. Extensive experiments on benchmarks, including the knowledge graph question-answer task and the long document reading comprehension task, show that Struct-X notably improves LLM reasoning, demonstrating the effectiveness of structured data augmentation in improving LLM inference with complex input context.

7/18/2024

Enhancing LLM's Cognition via Structurization

Kai Liu, Zhihang Fu, Chao Chen, Wei Zhang, Rongxin Jiang, Fan Zhou, Yaowu Chen, Yue Wu, Jieping Ye

When reading long-form text, human cognition is complex and structurized. While large language models (LLMs) process input contexts through a causal and sequential perspective, this approach can potentially limit their ability to handle intricate and complex inputs effectively. To enhance LLM's cognition capability, this paper presents a novel concept of context structurization. Specifically, we transform the plain, unordered contextual sentences into well-ordered and hierarchically structurized elements. By doing so, LLMs can better grasp intricate and extended contexts through precise attention and information-seeking along the organized structures. Extensive evaluations are conducted across various model architectures and sizes (including several 7B- to 72B-size auto-regressive LLMs as well as BERT-like masking models) on a diverse set of NLP tasks (e.g., context-based question-answering, exhaustive hallucination evaluation, and passage-level dense retrieval). Empirical results show consistent and significant performance gains afforded by a single-round structurization. In particular, we boost a 72B-parameter open-source model to achieve comparable performance against GPT-3.5-Turbo as the hallucination evaluator. Besides, we show the feasibility of distilling advanced LLMs' language processing abilities to a smaller yet effective StruXGPT-7B to execute structurization, addressing the practicality of our approach. Code will be made public soon.

7/24/2024

Reasoning Factual Knowledge in Structured Data with Large Language Models

Sirui Huang, Yanggan Gu, Xuming Hu, Zhonghao Li, Qing Li, Guandong Xu

Large language models (LLMs) have made remarkable progress in various natural language processing tasks as a benefit of their capability to comprehend and reason with factual knowledge. However, a significant amount of factual knowledge is stored in structured data, which possesses unique characteristics that differ from the unstructured texts used for pretraining. This difference can introduce imperceptible inference parameter deviations, posing challenges for LLMs in effectively utilizing and reasoning with structured data to accurately infer factual knowledge. To this end, we propose a benchmark named StructFact, to evaluate the structural reasoning capabilities of LLMs in inferring factual knowledge. StructFact comprises 8,340 factual questions encompassing various tasks, domains, timelines, and regions. This benchmark allows us to investigate the capability of LLMs across five factual tasks derived from the unique characteristics of structural facts. Extensive experiments on a set of LLMs with different training strategies reveal the limitations of current LLMs in inferring factual knowledge from structured data. We present this benchmark as a compass to navigate the strengths and weaknesses of LLMs in reasoning with structured data for knowledge-sensitive tasks, and to encourage advancements in related real-world applications. Please find our code at https://github.com/EganGu/StructFact.

8/23/2024

💬

New!StruEdit: Structured Outputs Enable the Fast and Accurate Knowledge Editing for Large Language Models

Baolong Bi, Shenghua Liu, Yiwei Wang, Lingrui Mei, Hongcheng Gao, Junfeng Fang, Xueqi Cheng

As the modern tool of choice for question answering, large language models (LLMs) are expected to deliver answers with up-to-date knowledge. To achieve such ideal question-answering systems, locating and then editing outdated knowledge in the natural language outputs is a general target of popular knowledge editing methods. However, this target is challenging, as both identifying which tokens to edit in the reasoning steps and ensuring the coherence of the revised reasoning chain are difficult tasks. We argue that these challenges stem from the unstructured nature of natural language outputs. To address the above challenges, we propose $textbf{Stru}$ctural $textbf{Edit}$ing ($textbf{StruEdit}$), an improved baseline for knowledge editing. We first prompt LLMs to produce structured outputs consisting of reasoning triplets. Then, StruEdit removes any potentially outdated knowledge and efficiently refills the structured outputs with up-to-date information in a single step. Experimental results show that StruEdit consistently delivers the highest accuracy with lowest latency compared with other knowledge editing methods.

9/17/2024