A Study on Incorporating Whisper for Robust Speech Assessment

Overview

• This research introduces an enhanced version of the multi-objective speech assessment model, MOSA-Net+, by leveraging the acoustic features from Whisper, a large-scaled weakly supervised model.
• The researchers investigate the effectiveness of Whisper in deploying a more robust speech assessment model and explore combining representations from Whisper and SSL (self-supervised learning) models.
• The experimental results reveal that Whisper's embedding features can contribute to more accurate prediction performance, while combining the embedding features from Whisper and SSL models only leads to marginal improvement.
• MOSA-Net+ outperforms intrusive methods, MOSA-Net, and other SSL-based speech assessment models in estimating subjective quality and intelligibility scores across all evaluation metrics in the Taiwan Mandarin Hearing In Noise test - Quality & Intelligibility (TMHINT-QI) dataset.
• MOSA-Net+ also obtained top-ranked performance among nine systems in the noisy-and-enhanced track of the VoiceMOS Challenge 2023, further validating its robustness.

Plain English Explanation

The researchers have developed an improved version of a speech assessment model called MOSA-Net+. This new model uses features extracted from Whisper, a large-scale AI model trained on a vast amount of speech data. By incorporating Whisper's acoustic features, the researchers aim to create a more robust and accurate speech assessment system.

The key idea is that Whisper's extensive training on a wide range of speech data can provide valuable information to help assess speech quality and intelligibility more effectively. The researchers found that using Whisper's features alone can lead to better prediction performance compared to other methods.

They also explored combining Whisper's features with those from other self-supervised learning (SSL) models, but this did not result in a significant further improvement. Nonetheless, the MOSA-Net+ model outperformed other existing methods, including intrusive approaches and previous versions of MOSA-Net, in estimating subjective speech quality and intelligibility scores on a Mandarin speech dataset.

To further validate the model's robustness, the researchers tested MOSA-Net+ in a speech quality assessment challenge, where it achieved the top performance among all the participating systems.

Technical Explanation

The researchers introduce an enhanced version of the MOSA-Net speech assessment model, called MOSA-Net+, by leveraging the acoustic features from Whisper, a large-scale weakly supervised model.

First, the researchers investigate the effectiveness of Whisper in deploying a more robust speech assessment model. They explore combining representations from Whisper and SSL models, as previous research has shown the potential of combining self-supervised representations for speech quality assessment.

The experimental results reveal that Whisper's embedding features can contribute to more accurate prediction performance. However, combining the embedding features from Whisper and SSL models only leads to marginal improvement.

Compared to intrusive methods, MOSA-Net, and other SSL-based speech assessment models, MOSA-Net+ yields notable improvements in estimating subjective quality and intelligibility scores across all evaluation metrics in the Taiwan Mandarin Hearing In Noise test - Quality & Intelligibility (TMHINT-QI) dataset.

To further validate its robustness, MOSA-Net+ was tested in the noisy-and-enhanced track of the VoiceMOS Challenge 2023, where it obtained the top-ranked performance among nine systems, demonstrating its efficiency in infusing self-supervised representations for automatic speech assessment.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a thorough evaluation of the MOSA-Net+ model and its performance compared to other speech assessment approaches. However, the researchers do not delve into potential limitations or areas for further research.

One potential concern is the reliance on the TMHINT-QI dataset, which may not fully capture the diversity of speech samples encountered in real-world scenarios. The researchers could consider evaluating the model's performance on a broader range of datasets to ensure its robustness.

Additionally, the paper does not discuss the computational complexity or resource requirements of the MOSA-Net+ model. As speech assessment models are often deployed in resource-constrained environments, such as mobile devices, understanding the model's efficiency would be valuable for practical applications.

Further research could explore the interpretability of the MOSA-Net+ model, providing insights into the specific acoustic features and their contributions to the speech assessment process. This could help researchers and practitioners better understand the model's decision-making and potentially lead to improvements in the future.

Conclusion

The research introduces an enhanced version of the MOSA-Net speech assessment model, MOSA-Net+, which leverages the acoustic features from the Whisper model. The experimental results demonstrate that Whisper's embedding features can contribute to more accurate prediction performance in estimating subjective speech quality and intelligibility.

MOSA-Net+ outperforms other intrusive methods, MOSA-Net, and SSL-based speech assessment models across various evaluation metrics. Furthermore, the model's top-ranked performance in the VoiceMOS Challenge 2023 validates its robustness and potential for practical applications in speech assessment and quality evaluation.

This research highlights the benefits of incorporating large-scale, weakly supervised models like Whisper to improve the accuracy and reliability of speech assessment systems. The findings have implications for developing more effective automated tools for speech quality analysis, which could be valuable in a wide range of applications, from communication systems to assistive technologies.