Towards Verifiable Text Generation with Symbolic References

Overview

• Large language models (LLMs) can generate human-like text, but their outputs often contain "hallucinations" or factual errors that require manual verification, especially for high-stakes applications.
• The researchers propose a technique called "symbolically grounded generation" (SymGen) to address this issue.
• SymGen prompts the LLM to interleave its output with explicit references to data fields, allowing for easier manual validation of the generated text.
• The researchers find that LLMs can successfully incorporate these symbolic references while maintaining fluency and factuality, and that the annotations can streamline human verification.

Plain English Explanation

The paper focuses on a challenge with large language models (LLMs) - they can sometimes generate text that includes made-up or incorrect information, known as "hallucinations." This is a problem, especially for important applications where the output needs to be 100% accurate.

To address this, the researchers developed a technique called "symbolically grounded generation" (SymGen). With SymGen, the LLM is prompted to include special markers or references in its output that point back to the original data sources. This allows human reviewers to quickly see where the information in the text is coming from, making it easier to verify that the LLM's output is accurate and truthful.

In their experiments, the researchers found that LLMs were able to successfully integrate these symbolic references into their text without losing coherence or factual correctness. And when humans reviewed the annotated text, they were able to validate the information more efficiently compared to text without the extra references.

Overall, this approach helps make LLM outputs more transparent and trustworthy, which is crucial for high-stakes applications like medical diagnosis or financial planning where mistakes could have serious consequences.

Technical Explanation

The researchers propose a technique called "symbolically grounded generation" (SymGen) to address the problem of hallucinations in large language models (LLMs). SymGen prompts the LLM to interleave its regular output text with explicit symbolic references to fields present in some conditioning data (e.g., a table in JSON format).

These symbolic references can be used to display the provenance of different spans of text in the generation, reducing the effort required for manual verification. For example, if the LLM generates text about a person's age, it might include a reference like "[AGE]" to indicate that this information came from the "age" field in the original data.

Across experiments on data-to-text generation and question-answering tasks, the researchers found that LLMs were able to successfully incorporate these symbolic references while maintaining fluency and factuality in the output. In a human study, they further demonstrated that the annotated text streamlined the process of verifying the accuracy of the LLM's outputs.

This work builds on prior research on techniques like code-aware prompting, knowledge-grounded text generation, and retrieval-augmented generation to reduce hallucinations in LLMs. By making the provenance of the text more transparent, SymGen represents a simple yet effective approach to enable easier manual validation of LLM outputs, which is crucial for high-stakes applications.

Critical Analysis

The researchers acknowledge some limitations of their work. For example, they note that SymGen may not be suitable for all types of generation tasks, such as open-ended creative writing. Additionally, the effectiveness of SymGen may depend on the quality and completeness of the conditioning data, which could be a challenge in real-world scenarios.

While the human study demonstrated the benefits of SymGen for streamlining verification, it would be valuable to further investigate the scalability and robustness of this approach as the size and complexity of the generated text increases. There may also be opportunities to explore more automated techniques for verifying LLM outputs, building on related research in deciphering textual authenticity.

Overall, the SymGen approach represents a promising step towards making LLM outputs more transparent and trustworthy. However, as with any technology, continued research and refinement will be necessary to address the evolving challenges and requirements of high-stakes applications.

Conclusion

The paper presents a technique called "symbolically grounded generation" (SymGen) to address the problem of hallucinations in large language models (LLMs). By prompting LLMs to interleave their outputs with explicit symbolic references to the underlying data, SymGen makes it easier for human reviewers to verify the accuracy and provenance of the generated text.

The researchers' experiments demonstrate that LLMs can successfully incorporate these symbolic references while maintaining fluency and factuality, and that the annotated text can streamline the human verification process. This work represents an important step towards enabling the safe and trustworthy deployment of LLMs in high-stakes applications where reliability is crucial.

As the capabilities of LLMs continue to advance, techniques like SymGen will become increasingly valuable in bridging the gap between the power of these models and the need for reliable, verifiable outputs. The research community's continued efforts to address the challenges of hallucination and transparency will be key to unlocking the full potential of large language models for the benefit of society.