Transformers as Decision Makers: Provable In-Context Reinforcement Learning via Supervised Pretraining

Read original: arXiv:2310.08566 - Published 5/28/2024 by Licong Lin, Yu Bai, Song Mei

🏅

Overview

Large transformer models can learn to make good decisions when prompted with interaction trajectories from unseen environments, a capability known as in-context reinforcement learning (ICRL).
However, it hasn't been well-understood when and how transformers can be trained to perform ICRL.
This paper provides a theoretical framework to analyze supervised pretraining for ICRL, including two recently proposed training methods: algorithm distillation and decision-pretrained transformers.

Plain English Explanation

Transformers are a type of machine learning model that have shown impressive abilities in a wide range of tasks, including learning how to make decisions in new environments based on examples of past interactions. This is known as in-context reinforcement learning (ICRL).

However, the exact details of how transformers can be trained to perform ICRL have been unclear. This paper provides a theoretical framework to better understand this process. The researchers look at two specific training methods:

Algorithm distillation: Training the transformer to mimic the decision-making of an "expert" reinforcement learning algorithm, using offline data.
Decision-pretrained transformers: Training the transformer to directly predict good decisions, also using offline data.

The paper analyzes the theoretical properties of these approaches, including how the transformer's performance is affected by factors like the quality of the offline training data and the complexity of the transformer model.

Overall, this research helps shed light on the ICRL capabilities of transformers and provides a foundation for further developing these powerful models for real-world decision-making tasks.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a theoretical framework to analyze the ICRL capabilities of transformers that have been pretrained on offline reinforcement learning (RL) datasets.

First, the researchers prove that under a "model realizability" assumption, a supervised-pretrained transformer will learn to imitate the conditional expectation of the expert RL algorithm, given the observed interaction trajectory. The generalization error of this imitation will scale with the transformer's model capacity and a distribution divergence factor between the expert and offline RL algorithms.

Second, the paper shows that transformers with ReLU attention can efficiently approximate near-optimal online RL algorithms like LinUCB and Thompson sampling for stochastic linear bandits, and UCB-VI for tabular Markov decision processes. This provides the first quantitative analysis of the ICRL capabilities of transformers pretrained from offline trajectories.

Critical Analysis

The paper provides a strong theoretical foundation for understanding the ICRL capabilities of pretrained transformers. However, the analysis relies on several assumptions, such as model realizability, that may not always hold in practice.

Additionally, the paper focuses on relatively simple RL settings like linear bandits and tabular MDPs. It remains to be seen how well the results generalize to more complex, real-world RL problems that transformers are often applied to.

Further research is needed to explore the ICRL performance of transformers in a wider range of environments, as well as to investigate potential limitations or biases that may arise from the offline pretraining process.

Conclusion

This paper offers important insights into the theoretical underpinnings of in-context reinforcement learning (ICRL) with pretrained transformers. By analyzing two specific training methods, the researchers provide a framework for understanding when and how transformers can learn to make good decisions in new environments based on past interaction data.

The findings suggest that transformers have the potential to efficiently approximate near-optimal RL algorithms, which could have significant implications for developing robust decision-making systems. However, further research is needed to fully explore the capabilities and limitations of this approach.

Overall, this work lays the groundwork for a better understanding of the ICRL capabilities of large language models, paving the way for more advanced and reliable AI-powered decision-making systems in the future.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏅

Transformers as Decision Makers: Provable In-Context Reinforcement Learning via Supervised Pretraining

Licong Lin, Yu Bai, Song Mei

Large transformer models pretrained on offline reinforcement learning datasets have demonstrated remarkable in-context reinforcement learning (ICRL) capabilities, where they can make good decisions when prompted with interaction trajectories from unseen environments. However, when and how transformers can be trained to perform ICRL have not been theoretically well-understood. In particular, it is unclear which reinforcement-learning algorithms transformers can perform in context, and how distribution mismatch in offline training data affects the learned algorithms. This paper provides a theoretical framework that analyzes supervised pretraining for ICRL. This includes two recently proposed training methods -- algorithm distillation and decision-pretrained transformers. First, assuming model realizability, we prove the supervised-pretrained transformer will imitate the conditional expectation of the expert algorithm given the observed trajectory. The generalization error will scale with model capacity and a distribution divergence factor between the expert and offline algorithms. Second, we show transformers with ReLU attention can efficiently approximate near-optimal online reinforcement learning algorithms like LinUCB and Thompson sampling for stochastic linear bandits, and UCB-VI for tabular Markov decision processes. This provides the first quantitative analysis of the ICRL capabilities of transformers pretrained from offline trajectories.

5/28/2024

🤔

Understanding the Training and Generalization of Pretrained Transformer for Sequential Decision Making

Hanzhao Wang, Yu Pan, Fupeng Sun, Shang Liu, Kalyan Talluri, Guanting Chen, Xiaocheng Li

In this paper, we consider the supervised pretrained transformer for a class of sequential decision-making problems. The class of considered problems is a subset of the general formulation of reinforcement learning in that there is no transition probability matrix, and the class of problems covers bandits, dynamic pricing, and newsvendor problems as special cases. Such a structure enables the use of optimal actions/decisions in the pretraining phase, and the usage also provides new insights for the training and generalization of the pretrained transformer. We first note that the training of the transformer model can be viewed as a performative prediction problem, and the existing methods and theories largely ignore or cannot resolve the arisen out-of-distribution issue. We propose a natural solution that includes the transformer-generated action sequences in the training procedure, and it enjoys better properties both numerically and theoretically. The availability of the optimal actions in the considered tasks also allows us to analyze the properties of the pretrained transformer as an algorithm and explains why it may lack exploration and how this can be automatically resolved. Numerically, we categorize the advantages of the pretrained transformer over the structured algorithms such as UCB and Thompson sampling into three cases: (i) it better utilizes the prior knowledge in the pretraining data; (ii) it can elegantly handle the misspecification issue suffered by the structured algorithms; (iii) for short time horizon such as $Tle50$, it behaves more greedy and enjoys much better regret than the structured algorithms which are designed for asymptotic optimality.

5/24/2024

In-Context Decision Transformer: Reinforcement Learning via Hierarchical Chain-of-Thought

Sili Huang, Jifeng Hu, Hechang Chen, Lichao Sun, Bo Yang

In-context learning is a promising approach for offline reinforcement learning (RL) to handle online tasks, which can be achieved by providing task prompts. Recent works demonstrated that in-context RL could emerge with self-improvement in a trial-and-error manner when treating RL tasks as an across-episodic sequential prediction problem. Despite the self-improvement not requiring gradient updates, current works still suffer from high computational costs when the across-episodic sequence increases with task horizons. To this end, we propose an In-context Decision Transformer (IDT) to achieve self-improvement in a high-level trial-and-error manner. Specifically, IDT is inspired by the efficient hierarchical structure of human decision-making and thus reconstructs the sequence to consist of high-level decisions instead of low-level actions that interact with environments. As one high-level decision can guide multi-step low-level actions, IDT naturally avoids excessively long sequences and solves online tasks more efficiently. Experimental results show that IDT achieves state-of-the-art in long-horizon tasks over current in-context RL methods. In particular, the online evaluation time of our IDT is textbf{36$times$} times faster than baselines in the D4RL benchmark and textbf{27$times$} times faster in the Grid World benchmark.

6/3/2024

Transformers are Minimax Optimal Nonparametric In-Context Learners

Juno Kim, Tai Nakamaki, Taiji Suzuki

In-context learning (ICL) of large language models has proven to be a surprisingly effective method of learning a new task from only a few demonstrative examples. In this paper, we study the efficacy of ICL from the viewpoint of statistical learning theory. We develop approximation and generalization error bounds for a transformer composed of a deep neural network and one linear attention layer, pretrained on nonparametric regression tasks sampled from general function spaces including the Besov space and piecewise $gamma$-smooth class. We show that sufficiently trained transformers can achieve -- and even improve upon -- the minimax optimal estimation risk in context by encoding the most relevant basis representations during pretraining. Our analysis extends to high-dimensional or sequential data and distinguishes the emph{pretraining} and emph{in-context} generalization gaps. Furthermore, we establish information-theoretic lower bounds for meta-learners w.r.t. both the number of tasks and in-context examples. These findings shed light on the roles of task diversity and representation learning for ICL.

8/23/2024