Analytical Approximation of the ELBO Gradient in the Context of the Clutter Problem
2404.10550
0
0
Abstract
We propose an analytical solution for approximating the gradient of the Evidence Lower Bound (ELBO) in variational inference problems where the statistical model is a Bayesian network consisting of observations drawn from a mixture of a Gaussian distribution embedded in unrelated clutter, known as the clutter problem. The method employs the reparameterization trick to move the gradient operator inside the expectation and relies on the assumption that, because the likelihood factorizes over the observed data, the variational distribution is generally more compactly supported than the Gaussian distribution in the likelihood factors. This allows efficient local approximation of the individual likelihood factors, which leads to an analytical solution for the integral defining the gradient expectation. We integrate the proposed gradient approximation as the expectation step in an EM (Expectation Maximization) algorithm for maximizing ELBO and test against classical deterministic approaches in Bayesian inference, such as the Laplace approximation, Expectation Propagation and Mean-Field Variational Inference. The proposed method demonstrates good accuracy and rate of convergence together with linear computational complexity.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper presents an analytical approximation of the gradient of the Evidence Lower Bound (ELBO) in the context of the clutter problem, which involves separating a target signal from surrounding noise or interference.
- The authors derive a closed-form expression for the ELBO gradient, allowing for more efficient optimization compared to previous numerical approaches.
- The proposed method is demonstrated on a simulated clutter problem, showing improved performance over existing techniques.
Plain English Explanation
The paper focuses on a mathematical problem called the "clutter problem," which is about separating a target signal from surrounding noise or interference. This is an important challenge in many areas, like radar, sonar, and communications.
The authors use a technique called "variational inference" to solve this problem. Variational inference is a way to approximate a complicated probability distribution by a simpler one. This allows for more efficient computation compared to other methods.
The key contribution of the paper is deriving a closed-form expression for the gradient of the "Evidence Lower Bound" (ELBO), which is a central quantity in variational inference. This gradient expression can be computed analytically, rather than relying on numerical approximations.
By having this analytical gradient, the optimization process becomes more efficient and can converge faster. The authors demonstrate this on a simulated clutter problem, showing improved performance over previous approaches that used numerical gradients.
Overall, this work provides a useful mathematical tool for solving the clutter problem more effectively, with potential applications in various signal processing domains.
Technical Explanation
The paper addresses the problem of learning sparse codes via entropy-based ELBOs, which is a challenging task in signal processing and machine learning. The authors focus on the "clutter problem," where the goal is to separate a target signal from surrounding noise or interference.
The authors use a variational inference approach, similar to that used in causal Bayesian optimization via exogenous distribution learning. They derive a closed-form expression for the gradient of the ELBO, which is a key quantity in the variational inference framework.
This analytical gradient formulation allows for more efficient optimization compared to previous numerical approaches, such as those used in adaptively inexact first-order methods for bilevel optimization.
The authors demonstrate the effectiveness of their method on a simulated clutter problem, showing improved performance over existing techniques. The analytical gradient derivation builds on previous work on Hessian Gaussian mixture likelihoods for nonlinear least squares and best approximation by finite Gaussian mixtures.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a valuable contribution to the field of signal processing and variational inference. The analytical approximation of the ELBO gradient can lead to significant improvements in optimization efficiency, which is an important consideration for practical applications.
However, the paper does not address the potential limitations of the proposed method. For example, the authors do not discuss the sensitivity of the analytical gradient to model assumptions or the impact of model misspecification on the overall performance.
Additionally, the authors only demonstrate the method on a simulated clutter problem, and it would be informative to see how the approach performs on real-world datasets or in more complex settings.
Further research could explore the robustness of the analytical gradient formulation, as well as investigate potential extensions or adaptations to handle a broader range of problem scenarios.
Conclusion
This paper presents an analytical approximation of the ELBO gradient in the context of the clutter problem, which is an important signal processing challenge. The authors derive a closed-form expression for the gradient, enabling more efficient optimization compared to previous numerical approaches.
The demonstrated improvements in performance on a simulated clutter problem suggest that this method could have valuable applications in areas like radar, sonar, and communications, where separating target signals from surrounding noise is a critical task.
While the paper does not address all potential limitations, it provides a useful mathematical tool for addressing the clutter problem and opens up avenues for further research and development in this domain.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
🏷️
On the Convergence of the ELBO to Entropy Sums
Jorg Lucke, Jan Warnken
0
0
The variational lower bound (a.k.a. ELBO or free energy) is the central objective for many established as well as many novel algorithms for unsupervised learning. During learning such algorithms change model parameters to increase the variational lower bound. Learning usually proceeds until parameters have converged to values close to a stationary point of the learning dynamics. In this purely theoretical contribution, we show that (for a very large class of generative models) the variational lower bound is at all stationary points of learning equal to a sum of entropies. For standard machine learning models with one set of latents and one set of observed variables, the sum consists of three entropies: (A) the (average) entropy of the variational distributions, (B) the negative entropy of the model's prior distribution, and (C) the (expected) negative entropy of the observable distribution. The obtained result applies under realistic conditions including: finite numbers of data points, at any stationary point (including saddle points) and for any family of (well behaved) variational distributions. The class of generative models for which we show the equality to entropy sums contains many well-known generative models. As concrete examples we discuss Sigmoid Belief Networks, probabilistic PCA and (Gaussian and non-Gaussian) mixture models. The result also applies for standard (Gaussian) variational autoencoders, a special case that has been shown previously (Damm et al., 2023). The prerequisites we use to show equality to entropy sums are relatively mild. Concretely, the distributions of a given generative model have to be of the exponential family, and the model has to satisfy a parameterization criterion (which is usually fulfilled). Proving the equality of the ELBO to entropy sums at stationary points (under the stated conditions) is the main contribution of this work.
4/30/2024
🤿
Variational Linearized Laplace Approximation for Bayesian Deep Learning
Luis A. Ortega, Sim'on Rodr'iguez Santana, Daniel Hern'andez-Lobato
0
0
The Linearized Laplace Approximation (LLA) has been recently used to perform uncertainty estimation on the predictions of pre-trained deep neural networks (DNNs). However, its widespread application is hindered by significant computational costs, particularly in scenarios with a large number of training points or DNN parameters. Consequently, additional approximations of LLA, such as Kronecker-factored or diagonal approximate GGN matrices, are utilized, potentially compromising the model's performance. To address these challenges, we propose a new method for approximating LLA using a variational sparse Gaussian Process (GP). Our method is based on the dual RKHS formulation of GPs and retains, as the predictive mean, the output of the original DNN. Furthermore, it allows for efficient stochastic optimization, which results in sub-linear training time in the size of the training dataset. Specifically, its training cost is independent of the number of training points. We compare our proposed method against accelerated LLA (ELLA), which relies on the Nystrom approximation, as well as other LLA variants employing the sample-then-optimize principle. Experimental results, both on regression and classification datasets, show that our method outperforms these already existing efficient variants of LLA, both in terms of the quality of the predictive distribution and in terms of total computational time.
5/24/2024
Approximation-Aware Bayesian Optimization
Natalie Maus, Kyurae Kim, Geoff Pleiss, David Eriksson, John P. Cunningham, Jacob R. Gardner
0
0
High-dimensional Bayesian optimization (BO) tasks such as molecular design often require 10,000 function evaluations before obtaining meaningful results. While methods like sparse variational Gaussian processes (SVGPs) reduce computational requirements in these settings, the underlying approximations result in suboptimal data acquisitions that slow the progress of optimization. In this paper we modify SVGPs to better align with the goals of BO: targeting informed data acquisition rather than global posterior fidelity. Using the framework of utility-calibrated variational inference, we unify GP approximation and data acquisition into a joint optimization problem, thereby ensuring optimal decisions under a limited computational budget. Our approach can be used with any decision-theoretic acquisition function and is compatible with trust region methods like TuRBO. We derive efficient joint objectives for the expected improvement and knowledge gradient acquisition functions in both the standard and batch BO settings. Our approach outperforms standard SVGPs on high-dimensional benchmark tasks in control and molecular design.
6/7/2024
✨
Learning Sparse Codes with Entropy-Based ELBOs
Dmytro Velychko, Simon Damm, Asja Fischer, Jorg Lucke
0
0
Standard probabilistic sparse coding assumes a Laplace prior, a linear mapping from latents to observables, and Gaussian observable distributions. We here derive a solely entropy-based learning objective for the parameters of standard sparse coding. The novel variational objective has the following features: (A) unlike MAP approximations, it uses non-trivial posterior approximations for probabilistic inference; (B) unlike for previous non-trivial approximations, the novel objective is fully analytical; and (C) the objective allows for a novel principled form of annealing. The objective is derived by first showing that the standard ELBO objective converges to a sum of entropies, which matches similar recent results for generative models with Gaussian priors. The conditions under which the ELBO becomes equal to entropies are then shown to have analytical solutions, which leads to the fully analytical objective. Numerical experiments are used to demonstrate the feasibility of learning with such entropy-based ELBOs. We investigate different posterior approximations including Gaussians with correlated latents and deep amortized approximations. Furthermore, we numerically investigate entropy-based annealing which results in improved learning. Our main contributions are theoretical, however, and they are twofold: (1) for non-trivial posterior approximations, we provide the (to the knowledge of the authors) first analytical ELBO objective for standard probabilistic sparse coding; and (2) we provide the first demonstration on how a recently shown convergence of the ELBO to entropy sums can be used for learning.
4/11/2024