Can LLMs Solve longer Math Word Problems Better?

Overview

• This paper explores the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to solve long and complex math word problems, which is crucial for their real-world applications.
• The researchers introduce a new benchmark dataset called "Extended Grade-School Math" (E-GSM) that contains math word problems with lengthy narratives.
• They also propose two novel metrics to assess the performance and resilience of LLMs in solving these long and complex problems.
• The study examines the limitations of existing zero-shot prompting techniques and both proprietary and open-source LLMs in solving long math word problems.
• The researchers propose different approaches to address these challenges for proprietary and open-source LLMs, respectively.

Plain English Explanation

Math word problems are an important way to evaluate the capabilities of large language models (LLMs), which are artificial intelligence systems that can understand and generate human language. Current research has focused on math problems with short and concise contexts. However, real-world math problems often involve complex and lengthy scenarios, and it's crucial for LLMs to be able to solve these long and detailed problems for practical applications.

This study aims to explore the ability of LLMs to handle long and complex math word problems, which the researchers call "Context Length Generalizability" (CoLeG). They introduce a new dataset called "Extended Grade-School Math" (E-GSM) that contains math word problems with lengthy narratives, and they also propose new ways to measure how well LLMs can solve these problems.

The researchers find that existing LLMs, both proprietary (owned by companies) and open-source (freely available), generally struggle with solving the long and complex math word problems in the E-GSM dataset. To address this, they develop different approaches for the two types of LLMs:

For proprietary LLMs, the researchers propose a new instructional prompt that can help mitigate the influence of the long context on the LLM's performance.

For open-source LLMs, the researchers create a new data augmentation task that can improve the LLM's ability to handle long and complex math word problems.

The study's comprehensive results show that these new approaches are effective, leading to improved performance on the E-GSM dataset as well as better performance on other math word problem benchmarks. This research paves the way for future work on using LLMs for real-world, complex applications, and it offers practical solutions to current limitations in this area.

Technical Explanation

The paper introduces the concept of Context Length Generalizability (CoLeG), which refers to the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to solve long and complex math word problems. This is an important capability for the practical application of LLMs in real-world scenarios, where math problems often involve lengthy narratives.

To explore CoLeG, the researchers develop a new benchmark dataset called Extended Grade-School Math (E-GSM), which contains math word problems with lengthy contexts. They also propose two novel metrics to assess the efficacy and resilience of LLMs in solving these long and complex problems.

The study examines the performance of existing zero-shot prompting techniques and both proprietary and open-source LLMs on the E-GSM dataset. The results reveal a general deficiency in CoLeG, highlighting the limitations of current approaches.

To address these challenges, the researchers propose distinct strategies for proprietary and open-source LLMs. For proprietary LLMs, they introduce a new instructional prompt to mitigate the influence of long contexts. For open-source LLMs, they develop a novel data augmentation task to improve CoLeG.

The comprehensive results demonstrate the effectiveness of these proposed methods, showing not only improved performance on the E-GSM dataset but also better generalization across several other math word problem benchmarks.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a valuable contribution to the field by addressing an important and underexplored aspect of LLM capabilities – their ability to handle long and complex math word problems. The introduction of the E-GSM dataset and the proposed evaluation metrics provide a valuable resource for the research community to further investigate CoLeG.

However, the paper does not explore the potential reasons behind the observed deficiencies in CoLeG for existing LLMs. It would be interesting to understand the specific architectural or training limitations that lead to this performance gap, as this could inform the development of more robust and generalizable LLM systems.

Additionally, the paper focuses on improving CoLeG through prompt engineering and data augmentation, but it does not explore other potential approaches, such as architectural modifications or specialized training regimes. Investigating a broader range of methods to enhance CoLeG could lead to even more effective solutions.

The GeoEval and MathIfy benchmarks could provide additional insights into the broader capabilities of LLMs in mathematical reasoning and problem-solving, which could complement the findings from this study.

Overall, this paper makes a significant contribution to the understanding and advancement of LLM capabilities in the context of long and complex math word problems, and it provides a solid foundation for future research in this area.

Conclusion

This study pioneers the exploration of Context Length Generalizability (CoLeG), the ability of Large Language Models (LLMs) to solve long and complex math word problems. By introducing the Extended Grade-School Math (E-GSM) dataset and novel evaluation metrics, the researchers uncover a general deficiency in the performance of existing LLMs on these types of problems.

To address this challenge, the paper proposes distinct approaches for proprietary and open-source LLMs, including a new instructional prompt and a data augmentation task, respectively. The comprehensive results demonstrate the effectiveness of these methods, showcasing improved performance not only on the E-GSM dataset but also on other math word problem benchmarks.

This research paves the way for future work on employing LLMs for real-world, complex applications, offering practical solutions to current limitations and opening new avenues for exploring model generalizability and training methodologies. The insights gained from this study can contribute to the development of more robust and versatile LLMs, expanding their capabilities to tackle the nuanced challenges present in real-world scenarios.