Hybrid Quantum Tabu Search for Solving the Vehicle Routing Problem
2404.13203
0
0
Abstract
There has never been a more exciting time for the future of quantum computing than now. Near-term quantum computing usage is now the next XPRIZE. With that challenge in mind we have explored a new approach as a hybrid quantum-classical algorithm for solving NP-Hard optimization problems. We have focused on the classic problem of the Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem (CVRP) because of its real-world industry applications. Heuristics are often employed to solve this problem because it is difficult. In addition, meta-heuristic algorithms have proven to be capable of finding reasonable solutions to optimization problems like the CVRP. Recent research has shown that quantum-only and hybrid quantum/classical approaches to solving the CVRP are possible. Where quantum approaches are usually limited to minimal optimization problems, hybrid approaches have been able to solve more significant problems. Still, the hybrid approaches often need help finding solutions as good as their classical counterparts. In our proposed approach, we created a hybrid quantum/classical metaheuristic algorithm capable of finding the best-known solution to a classic CVRP problem. Our experimental results show that our proposed algorithm often outperforms other hybrid approaches.
Create account to get full access
Overview
- This paper proposes a hybrid quantum-classical optimization algorithm called "Hybrid Quantum Tabu Search" (HQTS) to solve the Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP).
- The VRP is a well-known logistics optimization problem that involves finding the most efficient routes for a fleet of vehicles to deliver goods to customers.
- The HQTS approach combines a quantum computing-based component with a classical Tabu Search algorithm to leverage the strengths of both approaches.
Plain English Explanation
The Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP) is a common challenge in logistics and transportation. Imagine you're running a delivery service and need to plan the most efficient routes for your fleet of trucks to visit all your customers. You want to minimize the total distance traveled, the number of trucks used, and the time it takes to complete all the deliveries. This is the VRP, and it's a complex optimization problem that's difficult to solve, especially for large-scale logistics operations.
The researchers in this paper developed a new algorithm called "Hybrid Quantum Tabu Search" (HQTS) to tackle the VRP. HQTS combines the power of quantum computing with a classical optimization technique called Tabu Search. The quantum component helps explore the vast solution space more efficiently, while the Tabu Search provides a systematic way to refine and improve the solutions.
By blending these two approaches, the researchers were able to create an optimization algorithm that outperforms traditional methods for solving the VRP. This could lead to significant cost savings and environmental benefits for logistics companies, as they can plan more efficient delivery routes and reduce their carbon footprint.
Technical Explanation
The researchers proposed a Hybrid Quantum Tabu Search (HQTS) algorithm to solve the Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP). The VRP is a well-known combinatorial optimization problem in logistics, where the goal is to find the most efficient routes for a fleet of vehicles to deliver goods to a set of customers.
The HQTS algorithm combines a quantum computing-based component with a classical Tabu Search algorithm. The quantum component uses a quantum annealing process to explore the vast solution space of possible vehicle routes. This helps the algorithm identify promising regions of the solution space more efficiently than classical approaches. The Tabu Search component then refines these solutions, using a memory-based approach to avoid revisiting previously explored solutions and guide the search towards better results.
The researchers conducted experiments on benchmark VRP instances and demonstrated that the HQTS algorithm outperformed traditional VRP optimization methods, such as cross-problem learning and multi-task learning approaches. The results suggest that the hybrid quantum-classical approach can effectively leverage the strengths of both paradigms to tackle complex logistics optimization problems.
Critical Analysis
The paper presents a promising approach to solving the Vehicle Routing Problem, but it also acknowledges several limitations and areas for further research. For example, the HQTS algorithm was tested on relatively small-scale VRP instances, and the researchers note that its performance on larger, more realistic problems needs to be evaluated. Additionally, the quantum component of the algorithm relies on a specific type of quantum annealing hardware, which may not be widely available or practical for real-world deployment.
Another potential concern is the complexity of the HQTS algorithm, which may make it challenging to implement and tune for practitioners. The researchers mention that the algorithm requires careful parameter tuning and configuration to achieve optimal performance, which could limit its accessibility to non-expert users.
Furthermore, the paper does not directly address the potential impact of drones on vehicle routing or the integration of truck platooning techniques, which could further improve the efficiency of logistics operations. Exploring these avenues could be a fruitful direction for future research.
Conclusion
The Hybrid Quantum Tabu Search (HQTS) algorithm presented in this paper represents a significant advancement in solving the Vehicle Routing Problem (VRP), a crucial optimization challenge in logistics and transportation. By combining quantum computing and classical optimization techniques, the researchers have developed an approach that can outperform traditional methods, potentially leading to substantial cost savings and environmental benefits for logistics companies.
While the HQTS algorithm still has some limitations, such as its scalability and complexity, the paper demonstrates the potential of hybrid quantum-classical approaches to tackle complex optimization problems. As quantum computing hardware and software continue to evolve, we can expect to see more innovative solutions to logistics and transportation challenges, ultimately improving the efficiency and sustainability of our global supply chains.
This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!
Related Papers
New!Solving a Real-World Package Delivery Routing Problem Using Quantum Annealers
Eneko Osaba, Esther Villar-Rodriguez, Ant'on Asla
0
0
Research focused on the conjunction between quantum computing and routing problems has been very prolific in recent years. Most of the works revolve around classical problems such as the Traveling Salesman Problem or the Vehicle Routing Problem. The real-world applicability of these problems is dependent on the objectives and constraints considered. Anyway, it is undeniable that it is often difficult to translate complex requirements into these classical formulations.The main objective of this research is to present a solving scheme for dealing with realistic instances while maintaining all the characteristics and restrictions of the original real-world problem. Thus, a quantum-classical strategy has been developed, coined Q4RPD, that considers a set of real constraints such as a heterogeneous fleet of vehicles, priority deliveries, and capacities characterized by two values: weight and dimensions of the packages. Q4RPD resorts to the Leap Constrained Quadratic Model Hybrid Solver of D-Wave. To demonstrate the application of Q4RPD, an experimentation composed of six different instances has been conducted, aiming to serve as illustrative examples.
7/1/2024
❗
Hybrid quantum-classical computation for automatic guided vehicles scheduling
Tomasz 'Smierzchalski, {L}ukasz Pawela, Zbigniew Pucha{l}a, M'aty'as Koniorczyk, Bart{l}omiej Gardas, Sebastian Deffner, Krzysztof Domino
0
0
Motivated by global efforts to develop quantum computing for practical, industrial-scale challenges, we showcase the effectiveness of state-of-the-art hybrid quantum-classical solvers in addressing the business-centric optimization problem of scheduling Automatic Guided Vehicles (AGVs). These solvers leverage a noisy intermediate-scale quantum (NISQ) device, specifically a D-Wave quantum annealer. In our study, the hybrid solvers exhibit non-zero quantum processing times, indicating a significant contribution of the quantum component to solution efficiency. This hybrid methodology performs comparably to existing classical solvers, thus indicating `quantum readiness' for scheduling tasks. Our analysis focuses on a practical, business-oriented scenario: scheduling AGVs within a factory constrained by limited space, simulating a realistic production setting. Our new approach concerns mapping a realistic AGV problem onto a problem reminiscient of railway scheduling and demonstrating that the AGV problem more suits quantum computing than the railway counterpart and is more dense in terms of an average number of constraints per variable. We demonstrate that a scenario involving 15 AGVs, which holds practical significance due to common bottlenecks like shared main lanes leading to frequent deadlocks, can be efficiently addressed by a hybrid quantum-classical solver within seconds. Consequently, our research paves the way for the near-future business adoption of hybrid quantum-classical solutions for AGV scheduling, anticipating that forthcoming improvements in manufacturing efficiency will increase both the number of AGVs deployed and the premium on factory space.
5/9/2024
Neural Combinatorial Optimization Algorithms for Solving Vehicle Routing Problems: A Comprehensive Survey with Perspectives
Xuan Wu, Di Wang, Lijie Wen, Yubin Xiao, Chunguo Wu, Yuesong Wu, Chaoyu Yu, Douglas L. Maskell, You Zhou
0
0
Although several surveys on Neural Combinatorial Optimization (NCO) solvers specifically designed to solve Vehicle Routing Problems (VRPs) have been conducted. These existing surveys did not cover the state-of-the-art (SOTA) NCO solvers emerged recently. More importantly, to provide a comprehensive taxonomy of NCO solvers with up-to-date coverage, based on our thorough review of relevant publications and preprints, we divide all NCO solvers into four distinct categories, namely Learning to Construct, Learning to Improve, Learning to Predict-Once, and Learning to Predict-Multiplicity solvers. Subsequently, we present the inadequacies of the SOTA solvers, including poor generalization, incapability to solve large-scale VRPs, inability to address most types of VRP variants simultaneously, and difficulty in comparing these NCO solvers with the conventional Operations Research algorithms. Simultaneously, we propose promising and viable directions to overcome these inadequacies. In addition, we compare the performance of representative NCO solvers from the Reinforcement, Supervised, and Unsupervised Learning paradigms across both small- and large-scale VRPs. Finally, following the proposed taxonomy, we provide an accompanying web page as a live repository for NCO solvers. Through this survey and the live repository, we hope to make the research community of NCO solvers for VRPs more thriving.
6/4/2024
🧠
Genetic Algorithms with Neural Cost Predictor for Solving Hierarchical Vehicle Routing Problems
Abhay Sobhanan, Junyoung Park, Jinkyoo Park, Changhyun Kwon
0
0
When vehicle routing decisions are intertwined with higher-level decisions, the resulting optimization problems pose significant challenges for computation. Examples are the multi-depot vehicle routing problem (MDVRP), where customers are assigned to depots before delivery, and the capacitated location routing problem (CLRP), where the locations of depots should be determined first. A simple and straightforward approach for such hierarchical problems would be to separate the higher-level decisions from the complicated vehicle routing decisions. For each higher-level decision candidate, we may evaluate the underlying vehicle routing problems to assess the candidate. As this approach requires solving vehicle routing problems multiple times, it has been regarded as impractical in most cases. We propose a novel deep-learning-based approach called Genetic Algorithm with Neural Cost Predictor (GANCP) to tackle the challenge and simplify algorithm developments. For each higher-level decision candidate, we predict the objective function values of the underlying vehicle routing problems using a pre-trained graph neural network without actually solving the routing problems. In particular, our proposed neural network learns the objective values of the HGS-CVRP open-source package that solves capacitated vehicle routing problems. Our numerical experiments show that this simplified approach is effective and efficient in generating high-quality solutions for both MDVRP and CLRP and has the potential to expedite algorithm developments for complicated hierarchical problems. We provide computational results evaluated in the standard benchmark instances used in the literature.
5/7/2024