Searching by Code: a New SearchBySnippet Dataset and SnippeR Retrieval Model for Searching by Code Snippets

Overview

• The paper proposes a new dataset called "SearchBySnippet" to address the use case of searching for code samples and bugfixing instructions using a code snippet as the query, rather than just text.
• Existing code search datasets use code comments instead of full-text descriptions, making them unsuitable for this use case.
• The authors show that existing architectures perform poorly on the SearchBySnippet dataset, even after fine-tuning, and they present a new model called SnippeR that outperforms several baselines.

Plain English Explanation

When developers encounter a problem with their code, they often turn to online resources like StackOverflow to find solutions. However, the traditional way of searching for code, using text queries, may not be the most natural or effective approach in these situations.

Instead, developers might find it more intuitive to search using a code snippet - a small piece of their own code that is causing an issue - along with any associated error messages or tracebacks. This "search-by-code" use case is not well-covered by existing code search datasets, which tend to use code comments rather than full-text descriptions.

To address this gap, the researchers have created a new dataset called SearchBySnippet, based on StackOverflow data. They show that existing code search models struggle to perform well on this dataset, even after being fine-tuned. In response, the researchers present a new model called SnippeR that outperforms several strong baselines on the SearchBySnippet benchmark.

By introducing this new dataset and model, the researchers aim to provide a more relevant and challenging benchmark for evaluating code search systems, particularly in the context of finding bugfixing instructions and code samples using a code snippet as the query.

Technical Explanation

The paper focuses on the task of code search, which is typically performed by searching for code based on a text query. However, the authors argue that a more natural use case is searching for code samples and bugfixing instructions using a code snippet (and possibly an error traceback) as the query.

To explore this use case, the researchers introduce a new dataset called SearchBySnippet, which is based on StackOverflow data. Unlike existing code search datasets that use code comments as the textual information, SearchBySnippet contains full-text descriptions, making it more suitable for the search-by-code use case.

The authors evaluate several existing code search architectures, including Training Neural Networks to Explain Binaries, ReinforEST, and Advanced Detection of Source Code Clones via Ensemble, on the SearchBySnippet dataset. They find that these models perform poorly, even after fine-tuning, and are outperformed by a simple BM25 baseline.

To address this challenge, the researchers propose a new single encoder model called SnippeR, which outperforms several strong baselines on the SearchBySnippet dataset with a Recall@10 score of 0.451.

Critical Analysis

The researchers have identified an important and underexplored use case for code search, which is searching for code samples and bugfixing instructions using a code snippet as the query. The introduction of the SearchBySnippet dataset, which is based on real-world StackOverflow data, is a valuable contribution to the field.

However, the paper does not provide a detailed analysis of the limitations of existing code search datasets and architectures in the context of the search-by-code use case. It would have been helpful to understand the specific shortcomings of these models and datasets that led to their poor performance on the SearchBySnippet benchmark.

Additionally, the paper lacks a thorough discussion of the design choices and architectural details of the SnippeR model. While the authors demonstrate its superior performance, more insight into the model's inner workings and the rationale behind its design would help the reader better understand the technical contributions of the research.

Finally, the paper could have explored the potential challenges and limitations of the SearchBySnippet dataset, such as the quality and representativeness of the StackOverflow data, the diversity of the code snippets and descriptions, and the potential for bias or noise in the dataset.

Conclusion

The paper presents a novel approach to code search, focusing on the use case of searching for code samples and bugfixing instructions using a code snippet as the query. By introducing the SearchBySnippet dataset and the SnippeR model, the researchers have made important contributions to the field of code search.

The SearchBySnippet dataset provides a more relevant and challenging benchmark for evaluating code search systems, while the SnippeR model demonstrates the potential for improvements over existing architectures in this domain. These contributions have the potential to drive further advancements in code search and help developers more effectively find the resources they need to solve their coding problems.