Transferable Reward Learning by Dynamics-Agnostic Discriminator Ensemble

Read original: arXiv:2206.00238 - Published 6/27/2024 by Fan-Ming Luo, Xingchen Cao, Rong-Jun Qin, Yang Yu
Total Score

0

Sign in to get full access

or

If you already have an account, we'll log you in

Overview

  • This paper presents a new method called Dynamics-Agnostic Reward Learning (DARL) for recovering reward functions from expert demonstrations.
  • Classical reward learning methods like Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL) and Adversarial Imitation Learning (AIL) struggle with transferability, as the recovered reward functions are coupled with the training dynamics.
  • DARL decouples the reward function from the training dynamics, allowing for more transferable reward functions that can be used in different environments.
  • DARL also addresses the policy-dependency issue in the AIL framework, which further improves the transferability of the learned rewards.

Plain English Explanation

In reinforcement learning, a fundamental problem is

recovering the reward function
that captures the motivation of an expert demonstrator. By learning this reward function, agents can then
imitate the expert
by following the same rewards in their own environment, a process known as
apprentice learning
.

However, the challenge is that the agent may face

different environments
than the ones used in the expert demonstrations. So, we want to learn
transferable reward functions
that can work well in a variety of settings, not just the specific one used for training.

Classical reward learning methods like IRL and AIL struggle with this, as the reward functions they learn are

tied to the training dynamics
. This makes it hard to use them in new environments.

The new DARL method solves this by

decoupling the reward function from the training dynamics
. It does this by using a
dynamics-agnostic discriminator
that operates on a
latent space
derived from the original state-action space. This latent space is optimized to
minimize information about the dynamics
, allowing the reward function to be more transferable.

DARL also addresses another issue with the AIL framework called the

policy-dependency problem
. This problem can further reduce the transferability of the learned rewards. DARL represents the reward function as an
ensemble of discriminators
during training to
eliminate this policy dependency
.

Through experiments on MuJoCo tasks with changed dynamics, the paper shows that DARL

better recovers the reward function
and leads to
better imitation performance in transferred environments
, handling both state-only and state-action reward scenarios.

Technical Explanation

The key technical components of DARL are:

  1. Dynamics-Agnostic Discriminator: DARL employs a discriminator that operates on a latent space derived from the original state-action space. This latent space is optimized to minimize information about the training dynamics, allowing the reward function to be decoupled from the specific dynamics used during training.

  2. Ensemble of Discriminators: To address the policy-dependency issue in the AIL framework, DARL represents the reward function as an ensemble of discriminators during training. This eliminates the policy dependency, further improving the transferability of the learned rewards.

The paper evaluates DARL on MuJoCo tasks with changed dynamics, comparing it to classical reward learning methods like IRL and AIL, as well as other dynamics-agnostic and single-demonstration reward learning approaches. The results show that DARL

better recovers the reward function
and leads to
better imitation performance in transferred environments
, handling both state-only and state-action reward scenarios.

Critical Analysis

The paper makes a strong case for the importance of learning transferable reward functions in reinforcement learning. The DARL method represents a significant advancement over classical reward learning techniques, which struggle with transferability due to their coupling with the training dynamics.

However, the paper does not address the potential

computational complexity
of the ensemble of discriminators used in DARL. As the number of experts or demonstrations increases, the size of the discriminator ensemble could grow, potentially making the method less scalable.

Additionally, the paper focuses on

MuJoCo tasks
, which have relatively
simple dynamics
. It would be interesting to see how well DARL performs on more
complex, real-world environments
with high-dimensional state-action spaces and more complicated dynamics.

Finally, the paper does not discuss the

potential limitations
of the latent space optimization approach used to decouple the reward function from the dynamics. It would be valuable to understand the
boundary conditions
or
edge cases
where this approach may struggle to achieve the desired level of transferability.

Overall, the DARL method represents an important step forward in the field of reward learning and imitation learning. Further research to address the computational scalability and performance in more complex environments could help solidify DARL's position as a leading approach for recovering transferable reward functions.

Conclusion

This paper presents a new method called Dynamics-Agnostic Reward Learning (DARL) that addresses a key challenge in reinforcement learning: recovering reward functions from expert demonstrations that are

transferable to different environments
.

By decoupling the reward function from the training dynamics and addressing the policy-dependency issue in the AIL framework, DARL is able to learn more

transferable reward functions
that can be used effectively in a variety of settings, not just the specific one used for training.

The empirical results on MuJoCo tasks with changed dynamics show that DARL

outperforms
classical reward learning methods and other dynamics-agnostic approaches in terms of
recovering the true reward function
and
achieving better imitation performance
in the transferred environments.

This work represents an important step forward in the field of reward learning and imitation learning, and could have significant implications for building more

robust and adaptable reinforcement learning agents
that can effectively operate in a wide range of real-world scenarios.



This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

Total Score

0

Transferable Reward Learning by Dynamics-Agnostic Discriminator Ensemble

Fan-Ming Luo, Xingchen Cao, Rong-Jun Qin, Yang Yu

Recovering reward function from expert demonstrations is a fundamental problem in reinforcement learning. The recovered reward function captures the motivation of the expert. Agents can imitate experts by following these reward functions in their environment, which is known as apprentice learning. However, the agents may face environments different from the demonstrations, and therefore, desire transferable reward functions. Classical reward learning methods such as inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) or, equivalently, adversarial imitation learning (AIL), recover reward functions coupled with training dynamics, which are hard to be transferable. Previous dynamics-agnostic reward learning methods rely on assumptions such as that the reward function has to be state-only, restricting their applicability. In this work, we present a dynamics-agnostic discriminator-ensemble reward learning method (DARL) within the AIL framework, capable of learning both state-action and state-only reward functions. DARL achieves this by decoupling the reward function from training dynamics, employing a dynamics-agnostic discriminator on a latent space derived from the original state-action space. This latent space is optimized to minimize information on the dynamics. We moreover discover the policy-dependency issue of the AIL framework that reduces the transferability. DARL represents the reward function as an ensemble of discriminators during training to eliminate policy dependencies. Empirical studies on MuJoCo tasks with changed dynamics show that DARL better recovers the reward function and results in better imitation performance in transferred environments, handling both state-only and state-action reward scenarios.

Read more

6/27/2024

Diffusion-Reward Adversarial Imitation Learning
Total Score

0

Diffusion-Reward Adversarial Imitation Learning

Chun-Mao Lai, Hsiang-Chun Wang, Ping-Chun Hsieh, Yu-Chiang Frank Wang, Min-Hung Chen, Shao-Hua Sun

Imitation learning aims to learn a policy from observing expert demonstrations without access to reward signals from environments. Generative adversarial imitation learning (GAIL) formulates imitation learning as adversarial learning, employing a generator policy learning to imitate expert behaviors and discriminator learning to distinguish the expert demonstrations from agent trajectories. Despite its encouraging results, GAIL training is often brittle and unstable. Inspired by the recent dominance of diffusion models in generative modeling, this work proposes Diffusion-Reward Adversarial Imitation Learning (DRAIL), which integrates a diffusion model into GAIL, aiming to yield more precise and smoother rewards for policy learning. Specifically, we propose a diffusion discriminative classifier to construct an enhanced discriminator; then, we design diffusion rewards based on the classifier's output for policy learning. We conduct extensive experiments in navigation, manipulation, and locomotion, verifying DRAIL's effectiveness compared to prior imitation learning methods. Moreover, additional experimental results demonstrate the generalizability and data efficiency of DRAIL. Visualized learned reward functions of GAIL and DRAIL suggest that DRAIL can produce more precise and smoother rewards.

Read more

5/28/2024

Learning Causally Invariant Reward Functions from Diverse Demonstrations
Total Score

0

Learning Causally Invariant Reward Functions from Diverse Demonstrations

Ivan Ovinnikov, Eugene Bykovets, Joachim M. Buhmann

Inverse reinforcement learning methods aim to retrieve the reward function of a Markov decision process based on a dataset of expert demonstrations. The commonplace scarcity and heterogeneous sources of such demonstrations can lead to the absorption of spurious correlations in the data by the learned reward function. Consequently, this adaptation often exhibits behavioural overfitting to the expert data set when a policy is trained on the obtained reward function under distribution shift of the environment dynamics. In this work, we explore a novel regularization approach for inverse reinforcement learning methods based on the causal invariance principle with the goal of improved reward function generalization. By applying this regularization to both exact and approximate formulations of the learning task, we demonstrate superior policy performance when trained using the recovered reward functions in a transfer setting

Read more

9/14/2024

Towards the Transferability of Rewards Recovered via Regularized Inverse Reinforcement Learning
Total Score

0

Towards the Transferability of Rewards Recovered via Regularized Inverse Reinforcement Learning

Andreas Schlaginhaufen, Maryam Kamgarpour

Inverse reinforcement learning (IRL) aims to infer a reward from expert demonstrations, motivated by the idea that the reward, rather than the policy, is the most succinct and transferable description of a task [Ng et al., 2000]. However, the reward corresponding to an optimal policy is not unique, making it unclear if an IRL-learned reward is transferable to new transition laws in the sense that its optimal policy aligns with the optimal policy corresponding to the expert's true reward. Past work has addressed this problem only under the assumption of full access to the expert's policy, guaranteeing transferability when learning from two experts with the same reward but different transition laws that satisfy a specific rank condition [Rolland et al., 2022]. In this work, we show that the conditions developed under full access to the expert's policy cannot guarantee transferability in the more practical scenario where we have access only to demonstrations of the expert. Instead of a binary rank condition, we propose principal angles as a more refined measure of similarity and dissimilarity between transition laws. Based on this, we then establish two key results: 1) a sufficient condition for transferability to any transition laws when learning from at least two experts with sufficiently different transition laws, and 2) a sufficient condition for transferability to local changes in the transition law when learning from a single expert. Furthermore, we also provide a probably approximately correct (PAC) algorithm and an end-to-end analysis for learning transferable rewards from demonstrations of multiple experts.

Read more

6/5/2024