Workload-Aware Hardware Accelerator Mining for Distributed Deep Learning Training

Overview

• Presents a novel technique to search for hardware architectures of accelerators optimized for end-to-end training of deep neural networks (DNNs)
• Addresses both single-device and distributed pipeline and tensor model parallel training scenarios
• Optimizes accelerators for training metrics like throughput/TDP under fixed area and power constraints
• Tackles the large design space exploration problem using a heuristic-based critical path approach

Plain English Explanation

The paper introduces a new method to design specialized hardware, called accelerators, that can efficiently train deep learning models. Deep learning models are complex artificial intelligence algorithms that require a lot of computing power to train.

The researchers' approach can optimize accelerators for different training scenarios, including when the training is done on a single device or distributed across multiple devices. It focuses on maximizing the performance of the accelerator, such as how much data it can process per unit of power, while staying within fixed limits on physical size and power consumption.

Designing the best hardware for training deep learning models is challenging because there are many possible architectural choices. Prior work has tried to simplify this by only looking at one type of deep learning layer or just focusing on running the trained model, not the full training process. In contrast, this paper takes a more comprehensive approach that considers the entire training workflow.

The key innovation is a heuristic-based method that prioritizes allocating the accelerator's resources to the most critical computations in the deep learning model. This allows the system to efficiently explore the vast design space and find high-performing accelerator designs. For distributed training, the method selects the best combination of accelerator designs across the different stages of the training pipeline.

Technical Explanation

The paper presents a novel technique for hardware-aware neural architecture search to find optimized hardware accelerators for end-to-end training of deep neural networks.

The approach addresses both single-device and distributed pipeline and tensor model parallel training scenarios. It optimizes the accelerator designs for key training metrics like throughput per Watt, under fixed area and power constraints. This is important because the design space exploration for specialized DNN training accelerators is extremely large, with many possible architectural choices.

The key innovation is a heuristic-based critical path approach to efficiently explore this large design space. First, it performs a local search to determine the best architecture for each stage of the training pipeline or tensor model parallel computation. This uses a novel technique that prioritizes allocating accelerator resources to the most critical operators in the DNN workload.

To handle the complexities of distributed training, the local search selects multiple top candidate designs per stage. Then a global search identifies the best overall accelerator configuration by optimizing the training throughput across all the stages.

The paper evaluates this approach on 11 different DNN models. Compared to a recent inference-focused work called Spotlight, the proposed method converges to a design 31x faster on average and offers 12x higher training throughput. The generated accelerator designs also achieve 12% higher throughput than Google's TPU architecture.

Critical Analysis

The paper presents a comprehensive and innovative approach to hardware-aware neural architecture search for DNN training accelerators. By considering the full end-to-end training workflow, including both single-device and distributed scenarios, the researchers tackle a more realistic and challenging problem than prior work.

The heuristic-based critical path optimization technique is a clever way to navigate the vast design space efficiently. This builds on previous research in this area, but applies it in a novel context. The ability to select multiple top candidate designs per stage is also an important capability for handling the complexities of distributed training.

However, the paper does not provide much detail on the specific heuristics used or how they were developed. It would be helpful to understand the reasoning behind the prioritization of critical operators and other design choices. Additionally, the evaluation is limited to a set of 11 DNN models, so further testing on a wider range of workloads would strengthen the claims about the generalizability of the approach.

Another potential limitation is that the method still relies on simulations and modeling, rather than real hardware implementation. As noted in related work, there can be gaps between simulated and actual performance, so physical prototyping and testing would be an important next step.

Overall, this paper presents a promising technique that could significantly advance the state-of-the-art in hardware-aware neural architecture search for DNN training accelerators. Further research to refine the heuristics and validate the approach on real hardware would be valuable contributions to the field.

Conclusion

This paper introduces a novel hardware-aware neural architecture search technique to find optimized accelerator designs for end-to-end training of deep neural networks. The key innovation is a heuristic-based critical path approach that efficiently explores the vast design space, addressing both single-device and distributed training scenarios.

The proposed method demonstrates significant performance improvements over prior work, converging to high-throughput accelerator designs much faster and achieving up to 12% higher throughput than Google's TPU. This research represents an important step forward in developing specialized hardware to make deep learning more computationally efficient and accessible.

Further development and physical validation of this approach could lead to transformative advances in the underlying hardware that powers modern artificial intelligence systems. By co-designing the algorithms and the underlying computational substrate, researchers can unlock new capabilities and push the boundaries of what is possible with machine learning.