Reinforcement Learning Approaches for the Orienteering Problem with Stochastic and Dynamic Release Dates

Read original: arXiv:2207.00885 - Published 5/28/2024 by Yuanyuan Li, Claudia Archetti, Ivana Ljubic

🏅

Overview

The paper studies a sequential decision-making problem faced by e-commerce carriers related to when to send out a vehicle from the central depot to serve customer requests, and in which order to provide the service.
The key assumption is that the time at which parcels arrive at the depot is stochastic and dynamic.
The objective is to maximize the expected number of parcels that can be delivered during service hours.
The authors propose two reinforcement learning (RL) approaches to solve this problem.

Plain English Explanation

Imagine you're running a delivery service for an e-commerce company. Your job is to decide when to send out a delivery vehicle from the central depot and in what order to make the deliveries. The problem is that the arrival time of the packages at the depot is unpredictable and changes constantly. Your goal is to maximize the number of packages you can deliver during the available service hours.

The researchers in this paper developed two machine learning approaches to tackle this problem. These approaches use a "look-ahead" strategy, where they sample possible future arrival times of packages and use that information to plan the best routes. One approach combines this with a consensus function, and the other uses a two-stage stochastic optimization model. These methods are designed to be efficient and don't require extensive training, relying on a few key parameters and using powerful optimization techniques to make good decisions.

The researchers also identified some conditions that can help them partially understand the optimal delivery strategy, and they incorporated those insights into their machine learning approaches.

Technical Explanation

The researchers propose two reinforcement learning approaches to solve the sequential decision-making problem faced by e-commerce carriers:

VFA-CF (Value Function Approximation with Consensus Function): This approach uses a look-ahead strategy, where future release dates are sampled in a Monte-Carlo fashion, and a batch approach is used to approximate future routes. The value function is approximated, and a consensus function is used to make decisions.
VFA-2S (Value Function Approximation with Two-Stage Stochastic Optimization): This approach also uses a look-ahead strategy, but instead of the consensus function, it employs a two-stage stochastic integer linear programming (ILP) model to estimate future rewards.

Both VFA-CF and VFA-2S do not require extensive training, as they are based on a few hyperparameters and make good use of ILP and branch-and-cut-based exact methods to improve the quality of decisions.

The researchers also establish sufficient conditions for partial characterization of the optimal policy and integrate them into VFA-CF and VFA-2S.

In their empirical study, the researchers conduct a competitive analysis using upper bounds with perfect information. They show that VFA-CF and VFA-2S greatly outperform alternative approaches that:

Do not rely on future information
Are based on point estimation of future information
Employ heuristics rather than exact methods
Use exact evaluations of future rewards

Critical Analysis

The researchers have presented a novel and practical approach to solving the e-commerce delivery scheduling problem. By incorporating a look-ahead strategy and leveraging powerful optimization techniques, their methods appear to significantly outperform alternative approaches.

However, the paper does not address some potential limitations. For example, the assumption that the arrival time of parcels at the depot is stochastic and dynamic may not always hold in real-world scenarios. There may be patterns or seasonality in the arrival process that could be leveraged to improve the decision-making.

Additionally, the paper does not consider other factors that may influence the delivery process, such as traffic conditions, vehicle capacity, or driver availability. Incorporating these elements could make the model more comprehensive and applicable to a wider range of real-world situations.

Further research could explore the performance of these approaches in more complex environments, such as multi-vehicle routing or dynamic delivery scenarios. It would also be interesting to see how these methods compare to other state-of-the-art approaches in the field of vehicle routing and scheduling.

Conclusion

This paper presents two novel reinforcement learning approaches, VFA-CF and VFA-2S, to address the sequential decision-making problem faced by e-commerce carriers in managing their delivery operations. By leveraging a look-ahead strategy and powerful optimization techniques, these methods can significantly outperform alternative approaches that do not consider future information or rely on heuristics.

The researchers' work contributes to the ongoing efforts to improve the efficiency and responsiveness of e-commerce delivery systems, which are becoming increasingly important as online shopping continues to grow. While the paper has some limitations, the proposed approaches demonstrate the potential of machine learning and optimization to tackle complex logistical challenges in the modern economy.

This summary was produced with help from an AI and may contain inaccuracies - check out the links to read the original source documents!

Follow @aimodelsfyi on 𝕏 →

Related Papers

🏅

Reinforcement Learning Approaches for the Orienteering Problem with Stochastic and Dynamic Release Dates

Yuanyuan Li, Claudia Archetti, Ivana Ljubic

In this paper, we study a sequential decision-making problem faced by e-commerce carriers related to when to send out a vehicle from the central depot to serve customer requests, and in which order to provide the service, under the assumption that the time at which parcels arrive at the depot is stochastic and dynamic. The objective is to maximize the expected number of parcels that can be delivered during service hours. We propose two reinforcement learning (RL) approaches for solving this problem. These approaches rely on a look-ahead strategy in which future release dates are sampled in a Monte-Carlo fashion and a batch approach is used to approximate future routes. Both RL approaches are based on value function approximation - one combines it with a consensus function (VFA-CF) and the other one with a two-stage stochastic integer linear programming model (VFA-2S). VFA-CF and VFA-2S do not need extensive training as they are based on very few hyper-parameters and make good use of integer linear programming (ILP) and branch-and-cut-based exact methods to improve the quality of decisions. We also establish sufficient conditions for partial characterization of optimal policy and integrate them into VFA-CF/VFA-2S. In an empirical study, we conduct a competitive analysis using upper bounds with perfect information. We also show that VFA-CF and VFA-2S greatly outperform alternative approaches that: 1) do not rely on future information, or 2) are based on point estimation of future information, or 3) employ heuristics rather than exact methods, or 4) use exact evaluations of future rewards.

5/28/2024

🏅

Using Reinforcement Learning for the Three-Dimensional Loading Capacitated Vehicle Routing Problem

Stefan Schoepf, Stephen Mak, Julian Senoner, Liming Xu, Netland Torbjorn, Alexandra Brintrup

Heavy goods vehicles are vital backbones of the supply chain delivery system but also contribute significantly to carbon emissions with only 60% loading efficiency in the United Kingdom. Collaborative vehicle routing has been proposed as a solution to increase efficiency, but challenges remain to make this a possibility. One key challenge is the efficient computation of viable solutions for co-loading and routing. Current operations research methods suffer from non-linear scaling with increasing problem size and are therefore bound to limited geographic areas to compute results in time for day-to-day operations. This only allows for local optima in routing and leaves global optimisation potential untouched. We develop a reinforcement learning model to solve the three-dimensional loading capacitated vehicle routing problem in approximately linear time. While this problem has been studied extensively in operations research, no publications on solving it with reinforcement learning exist. We demonstrate the favourable scaling of our reinforcement learning model and benchmark our routing performance against state-of-the-art methods. The model performs within an average gap of 3.83% to 8.10% compared to established methods. Our model not only represents a promising first step towards large-scale logistics optimisation with reinforcement learning but also lays the foundation for this research stream. GitHub: https://github.com/if-loops/3L-CVRP

6/12/2024

Deep Reinforcement Learning for Multi-Truck Vehicle Routing Problems with Multi-Leg Demand Routes

Joshua Levin, Randall Correll, Takanori Ide, Takafumi Suzuki, Takaho Saito, Alan Arai

Deep reinforcement learning (RL) has been shown to be effective in producing approximate solutions to some vehicle routing problems (VRPs), especially when using policies generated by encoder-decoder attention mechanisms. While these techniques have been quite successful for relatively simple problem instances, there are still under-researched and highly complex VRP variants for which no effective RL method has been demonstrated. In this work we focus on one such VRP variant, which contains multiple trucks and multi-leg routing requirements. In these problems, demand is required to move along sequences of nodes, instead of just from a start node to an end node. With the goal of making deep RL a viable strategy for real-world industrial-scale supply chain logistics, we develop new extensions to existing encoder-decoder attention models which allow them to handle multiple trucks and multi-leg routing requirements. Our models have the advantage that they can be trained for a small number of trucks and nodes, and then embedded into a large supply chain to yield solutions for larger numbers of trucks and nodes. We test our approach on a real supply chain environment arising in the operations of Japanese automotive parts manufacturer Aisin Corporation, and find that our algorithm outperforms Aisin's previous best solution.

8/28/2024

🏅

Actively Learning Reinforcement Learning: A Stochastic Optimal Control Approach

Mohammad S. Ramadan, Mahmoud A. Hayajnh, Michael T. Tolley, Kyriakos G. Vamvoudakis

In this paper we propose a framework towards achieving two intertwined objectives: (i) equipping reinforcement learning with active exploration and deliberate information gathering, such that it regulates state and parameter uncertainties resulting from modeling mismatches and noisy sensory; and (ii) overcoming the computational intractability of stochastic optimal control. We approach both objectives by using reinforcement learning to compute the stochastic optimal control law. On one hand, we avoid the curse of dimensionality prohibiting the direct solution of the stochastic dynamic programming equation. On the other hand, the resulting stochastic optimal control reinforcement learning agent admits caution and probing, that is, optimal online exploration and exploitation. Unlike fixed exploration and exploitation balance, caution and probing are employed automatically by the controller in real-time, even after the learning process is terminated. We conclude the paper with a numerical simulation, illustrating how a Linear Quadratic Regulator with the certainty equivalence assumption may lead to poor performance and filter divergence, while our proposed approach is stabilizing, of an acceptable performance, and computationally convenient.

9/10/2024